Rajapakse லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி
Rajapakse லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி

வியாழன், 19 செப்டம்பர், 2013

Politicization of war-crimes: Bashir and Rajapakse

Politicization of war-crimes: Bashir and Rajapakse

[TamilNet, Thursday, 19 September 2013, 10:58 GMT]
While Sri Lanka's President Mahinda Rajapaksa, under whose command responsibility the Sri Lanka military killed nearly UN-estimated 100,000 Tamil civilians, is attending the 62nd United Nations General Assembly, commencing on September 25, the White House is not commenting on if the US would be issuing an entry visa to alleged war-criminal and Sudan's long time leader Hassan al-Bashir to attend the UN annual meeting. Recently, the US State Department, using its discretionary powers, intervened to save Rajapakse from war-crimes charges in Court cases filed by affected Tamils.

“We have an obligation as host nation for the U.N.,” State Department spokeswoman Marie Harf said, referring to the general practice of allowing foreign leaders and diplomats entry to the United States for U.N. business. “I’m just not going to speculate what action we may or may not take other than to say we act consistent with our relevant international obligation,” the Washington Post reported.

U.N. Ambassador Samantha Power started a diplomatic shoving match Monday when she said the United States had received a request for an entry visa from Sudanese President Omar Hassan al-Bashir. It would be “deplorable, cynical and hugely inappropriate” for Bashir to attend the U.N. gathering, Power said, according to the paper.

A spokesperson for US-based activist organization, Tamils Against Genocide (TAG), commenting on the issue said, "The State Department's silence on whether it will allow genocide-indicted Sudanese leader al-Bashir an entry visa is symptomatic of customary American dualistic approaches to human rights enforcement. The question of whether or not al-Bashir should be permitted to attend on American soil is a Red Herring. It obfuscates the question of American intent to enforce international criminal prohibitions on genocide, and its obligation as a UN member to extradite al-Bashir to the Hague if he were present on American territory. If the recurrent presence of Mahinda Rajapakse on American soil during and after the Tamil killing field in Mu'l'livaaykkaal is a precedent, President al-Bashir should not be alarmed by the paroxysm of public discussion."

Sudan’s Foreign Ministry commenting on the US stance, said, the United States is not qualified “to offer sermons and advice” on human rights or international law, in particular because Washington is not a member of the international court and considers itself independent of the court’s decisions. Bashir should be quickly granted a visa to visit New York, the government in Khartoum said.

Professor Boyle, an expert in international law earlier said, "[Samantha] Power stood by and watched 150,000 Tamils be exterminated by the GOSL and did nothing to stop it that I am aware of," and pointing out Power's conspicuous silence during the killing of Tamil civilians reaching genocidal proportions by the Sri Lanka military, said that Power now [at the UN] has a chance to "redeem" herself by establishing an International Criminal Tribunal for Sri Lanka, as did her predecessor Madeline Albright to the former Yugoslavia.

Related Articles:
20.07.13   Can Power, silent on Sri Lanka genocide, redeem herself in U..
06.06.13   Spectators to Sri Lanka genocide ascend in Obama's inner cir..
31.03.13   ICC's focus on Africa examined
31.03.13   Rajapakse immune from war crime charges while in office, rul..
22.03.13   Genocidal double talk by India, US - Prof. Boyle
09.03.13   U.S. judges, Fein in oral legal battle over war-crimes immun..
08.03.13   US UNHRC inaction not inconsistent with saving Rajapakse in ..
22.02.13   Blake, architect of Tamil tragedy, spectator to genocide
08.12.12   Fein: U.S.'s immunity determinations flout due process
01.12.12   Rice's silence on Sri Lanka may hurt cabinet appointment - p..
09.11.12   U.S. reasserts immunity to Rajapakse from war crimes
29.04.12   Samantha Power to chair US genocide prevention effort


External Links:
WP: State Department mum on entry visa for Sudanese president to attend U.N. meeting

திங்கள், 1 ஏப்ரல், 2013

Rajapakse immune from war crime charges

Rajapakse immune from war crime charges while in office, rules US Court

[TamilNet, Sunday, 31 March 2013, 12:04 GMT]
United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia circuit in the opinion delivered this week on the appeal case against Sri Lanka's President Rajpakse filed by three Tamil plaintiffs claiming civil damages on war-crimes charges ruled that "as a consequence of the [U.S.] State Department’s suggestion of immunity, the defendant [Rajapakse] is entitled to head of state immunity under the common law while he remains in office...," and affirmed the judgment of the district court dismissing the plaintiffs’ complaint. The plaintiffs' attorney Bruce Fein told TamilNet that he will advise his clients and the sponsoring organization if they should consider filing a writ of certiorari keep the option open to move the case further forward to the Supreme Court.

The oral argument was heard by a three-judge court consisting of Judges Merrick Garland, Janice Brown, and Brett Kavanaugh.
The Court said that the Common Law relevant to the issue of immunity is established, and that “the diplomatic representative of the sovereign could request a ‘suggestion of immunity’ from the State Department,” and “[i]f the request was granted, the district court surrendered its jurisdiction.
Dr Kasippillai Manoharan
Dr Kasippillai Manoharan
Bruce Fein, former US Associate Deputy Attorney General
Bruce Fein, former US Associate Deputy Attorney General
The Court said that, therefore, it has no jurisdiction unless Congress intended the TVPA [Torture Victims Protection Act] to supersede the common law which governs the issue for the case at bar, as the court recognized that “The canon of construction that statutes should be interpreted consistently with the common law helps us interpret a statute that,” as here, “clearly covers a field formerly governed by the common law.

The court then considered "the language of the TVPA," to interpret if the Congress intended "torture," a crime accepted as a universal crime under international law, as a narrow exception to granting immunity to "an individual" including head of states.

The court said,"...plaintiffs contend supersedes the common law because it renders “an individual” liable for damages in a civil action, and a head of state is “an individual.” But as even the plaintiffs acknowledge, the term “an individual” cannot be read to cover every individual; plaintiffs agree that both diplomats and visiting heads of state retain immunity when they visit the United States.

Referring to an analogous statute the court concluded that "Congress did not intend that language to abrogate the preexisting common law of immunity applicable to executive officials," and "that the common law of head of state immunity survived enactment of the TVPA."

The spokesperson for the US-based activist group, Tamils Against Genocide [TAG] which seeks judicial redress for Tamil victims of war including sponsoring this case, commented: "Under contemporary norms of international human rights, head of States are not entitled to immunity for jus cogens norms violations. The appellate court's interpretation of common law immunity doctrine is incompatible with the universally recognized prohibitions of torture and crimes against humanity. If the ruling stands, the State Department's intervention to save Rajapakse symbolizes the human rights double standard at the center of the Obama administration's foreign policy, preaching its inviolability abroad, while pardoning it at home, in America's own courts," TAG said of the decision.

The complaint was filed first in 2011 at the District Court for this case alleged multiple violations of the Torture Victims Protection Act (TVPA) based on Sri Lanka's President Rajapaksa’s command responsibility for the extrajudicial killings of Ragihar Manoharan, the son of Plaintiff Dr. Kasippillai Manoharan, of Premas Anandarajah, a humanitarian aid worker for Action Against Hunger, and husband of Plaintiff Kalaiselvi Lavan, and four members of the Thevarajah family, all relatives of Plaintiff Jeyakumar Aiyathurai.

After the intervention of the U.S. Justice Department which "suggested" Head of State immunity, the trial court dismissed the case. The plaintiffs appealed.

Related Articles:
09.03.13   U.S. judges, Fein in oral legal battle over war-crimes immun..

வெள்ளி, 8 மார்ச், 2013

US UNHRC inaction not inconsistent with saving Rajapakse

US UNHRC inaction not inconsistent with saving Rajapakse in US Courts, says TAG

[TamilNet, Friday, 08 March 2013, 01:03 GMT]
The resolution tabled in the Geneva UNHCR sessions by the USA in concert with India, which sidesteps forcing an independent international investigation into the Mu'l'livaaykaal killings, and misleads the Eezham Tamils into a mirage that international community will seek accountability, appears entirely consistent with the intervention of the U.S. State Department in the legal actions pursued by Tamil plaintiffs against Sri Lanka's President Rajapakse, legal sources in Washington said. U.S. is acting as a proxy to Rajapakses in filing legal briefs and replacing Patton Boggs as "the attorneys" for Rajapakse.

"The U.S. State Department exercising the discretionary powers to intervene legally in the case against Rajapakse effectively blocks a pre-trial discovery process which would have uncovered facts related to the Sri Lanka killings. Therefore, this US intervention is not inconsistent with the resolution which does not call for an independent international investigation," spokesperson for Tamils Against Genocide (TAG), a US-based activist organization that seeks legal redress to Tamil victims war, said.

United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia circuit has scheduled March 8th, 9:30 am for the oral argument in the appeal case against Sri Lanka's President Mahinda Rajapakse for civil damages on war-crimes charges filed by three Tamil plaintiffs whose relatives were extra-judicially executed or unlawfully killed under the "command responsibility" of Rajapakse.

United States Justice Department lawyers, under the direction from the State Department, will present the legal oral argument supporting immunity to Defendant-Appellee Rajapakse, legal sources in Washington said. Rajapakse appointed attorneys at Patton Boggs, a large law firm in Washington D.C. will concede their full allocagted time to the US Government to argue the case for Rajapakse, the procedural motions in the case docket indicated.

"The U.S. Government has affirmatively exercised its option, first in the trial court, and now in the appellate court, to intervene to save Rajapakse from legal action by legitimate victims of his allegedly murderous conduct. Ambassador Blake architected policy of appeasing Sri Lanka overlooking the killing more than 80,000 Tamil civilians in Mu'l'livaaykkaal, appears to have even trumped Sri Lanka's continued dismissal of the chorus of disapproval from the West on autocracy-leaning governance matters in Colombo," TAG spokesperson said in an earlier note to TamilNet.

Chronology:


Related Articles:
07.03.13   Learn Lesson and Respond Concretely: ‘LLRC’ for Tamils on US..
22.02.13   Blake, architect of Tamil tragedy, spectator to genocide
06.04.12   Boyle compares Syria action, dismisses UNHRC resolution as a..
30.01.12   Boyle: US should publicly accuse Colombo of committing war c..
23.01.11   TAG to file civil case against Rajapakse in Texas Federal Co..
13.11.10   Demand US to provide war crimes evidence to UN Panel, urges ..
13.03.10   Demand US to reveal more inculpatory war crimes evidence, ur..

வெள்ளி, 1 பிப்ரவரி, 2013

Refugee boat surge to Australia linked to profiteering

Refugee boat surge to Australia linked to profiteering by Rajapakse ally

[TamilNet, Friday, 01 February 2013, 02:31 GMT]
Australia's Intelligence services linked a senior Sri Lankan government official who is close to Sri Lanka's president Rajapakse as responsible for "authorizing numerous boats in the past 10 months, fuelling the surge of asylum-seekers from Sri Lanka that has threatened to overwhelm Australia's detention system," The Australian reported Friday. While the complicity of this official in people smuggling was widely known at senior levels of the Gillard government, Foreign Minister Bob Carr during his visit to Sri Lanka in December never raised the matter with the Sri Lankan government, the paper pointed out.
Bob Carr, Minister for Foreign Affairs, Australia
Bob Carr, Minister for Foreign Affairs, Australia
"While official corruption is a common feature of the people-smuggling industry across the world, the involvement of such a senior member of the government would appear to be unprecedented. The assessment inside the Australian government is that the official is "complicit" in people-smuggling, posing a serious obstacle to Australia's attempts to stop the flow of boats from Sri Lanka," the paper said.

Speaking on behalf of the Australian government, a spokesman for Immigration Minister Chris Bowen said the government was working closely with the Sri Lankans to break the smuggling syndicates, but declined to address the allegations against the official directly. "As you know, we do not publicly discuss people-smuggling or national security intelligence," the paper quoted the spokesman as saying.

Colombo's senior envoy to Australia flatly denied the allegations and described the allegations as a "smear campaign against the (official)".

According to Customs and Border Protection, a total of 122 asylum boats left Sri Lanka for Australia last year, with the first arriving in February.
A spokesman for the Australia-based Tamil Refugee Council (TRC), Trevor Grant, said in a press release: “We have suspected this all along. It would be virtually impossible for so many boats to leave such a small island without co-operation from the Sri Lankan Navy, and its Government...Even when the Foreign Minister Bob Carr went to Sri Lanka last December to talk about the increased flow of asylum-seeker boats with high-ranking officials, including the president, he did not mention it. Yet at the same time he offered $45 million of Australian taxpayers’ money to supposedly help stop the boats, knowing full well that there was corruption going on within Government ranks," Mr Grant said.
Julie Bishop, Opposition Deputy Leader
Julie Bishop, Opposition Deputy Leader
Meanwhile, TRC also accused the opposition Foreign Affairs spokesperson, Julie Bishop, for giving a misleading account of her meeting with Tamil representatives during her visit to Sri Lanka, according to a Tamil MP who spoke to her at length. Bishop had told listeners to ABC Radio’s Connect Asia program on Tuesday that she had spoken to Tamil National Alliance MPs, and other Tamil people in the north, where most Tamils live, and had seen or heard no evidence of persecution of Tamils. TRC pointed out that Tamil National Alliance MP Sivagnanam Sritharan contradicted Bishop's assertions in a recent Canadian Tamil Radio interview.

External Links:
AU: Blow to asylum battle as intelligence links Sri Lankan official to smugglers

வெள்ளி, 23 நவம்பர், 2012

Appellants granted time extention in Rajapakse war-crimes case

Appellants granted time extention in Rajapakse war-crimes case

[TamilNet, Thursday, 22 November 2012, 15:41 GMT]
The United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit granted appellants’ motion for extension of time to file the Reply brief, by two weeks, in the appeal case against Sri Lanka's President Mahinda Rajapakse for civil damages on war-crimes charges, according to the court docket. The revised briefing schedule indicated that the Appellant's Reply brief will now have to be filed by December 7, 2012. Attorney for the Appellants, Bruce Fein, told the court that the the intervening holidays and his case work load had necessitated the request for extension and the Court granted his motion.

The Appellant attorney affirmed that "[t]he motion has not been filed for the purpose of delay or other improper purpose. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (FRCP)-11 (c)(1) allows the Court to impose sanctions on the attorney or law firm if the court determines that the motion is "being presented for an improper purpose, such as to harass, cause unnecessary delay, or needlessly increase the cost of litigation."

The case filed by three Tamil plaintiffs is on appeal from a final order dismissing the complaint for lack of jurisdiction based on a suggestion of immunity for Rajapakse filed by the Department of Justice on behalf of the Department of State.

The complaint was filed first in 2011 at the District Court for this case alleged multiple violations of the Torture Victims Protection Act (TVPA) based on Sri Lanka's President Rajapaksa’s command responsibility for the extrajudicial killings of Ragihar Manoharan, the son of Plaintiff Dr. Kasippillai Manoharan, of Premas Anandarajah, a humanitarian aid worker for Action Against Hunger, and husband of Plaintiff Kalaiselvi Lavan, and four members of the Thevarajah family, all relatives of Plaintiff Jeyakumar Aiyathurai.

Chronology:

சனி, 3 நவம்பர், 2012

Rajapakse depends on U.S. to defend War Crimes charges

Rajapakse depends on U.S. to defend War Crimes charges

[TamilNet, Friday, 02 November 2012, 00:48 GMT]
Sri Lanka's President Mahinda Rajapakse filed his reply brief at the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Thurdsay in response to the opening brief filed by the three Tamil Plaintiffs-Appellants in the case, Kasippillai Manoharan versus Percy Mahendra Rajpakse, attorney for the appellants Bruce Fein said. "Rajapakse attorneys again appear to depend on the Department of Justice of the United States to reassert the "suggestion of immunity" and for the Appeals judges accept, as did the trial court, to defend Rajapakse on the charges of war-crimes," legal sources in Washington said.

The appeal was filed by three Tamils against Rajapakse for complicity in extrajudicial killings of plaintiffs relatives in violation of the Torture Victims Protection Act (TVPA). The case, first filed at the lower court, was dismissed in February 2012 by Judge Kotelly after the U.S. State Department intervened to assert that, as a sitting head of state, Rajapakse was immune from litigation.

Mitchell Berger and Benjamin Wood at the Washington Law firm Patton Boggs LLP, appearing as Counsel for Mahinda Rajapaksa, in the brief, argue that,
    rajapakse
  • Rajapaksa did Not Appear on the Merits in the District Court and Expressly Reserved All Jurisdictional and Other Defenses,
  • The United States’ Suggestion of Immunity Bound the District Court and Divested It of Jurisdiction, and
  • The United States, Expected to Participate as Amicus Curiae, Is the Proper Party to Advocate for Affirmance of the District Court Decision.
In addition to other cases, the Appellee's attorneys cite Belhas v. Moshe Ya’Alon, 515 F.3d 1279, 1287 (D.C. Cir. 2008), that the pre- Samantar holding that TVPA did not eliminate foreign official immunity under the FSIA even for alleged jus cogens violations.

The appellants' had, in the opening brief, argued that District Court erred in the following legal issues when rendering the earlier ruling dismissing the case:
    Bruce Fein, former US Associate Deputy Attorney General
    Bruce Fein, former US Associate Deputy Attorney General
  • the Court "erred in conceiving Customary International Law (CIL) as including discretionary as opposed to obligatory rules and by slighting the Convention Against Torture and the Rome Statute in determining whether CIL has evolved since the TVPA to permit civil suits against sitting heads of state for the universal crimes of torture and extrajudicial killing which do not paralyze a foreign government as would a criminal arrest or imprisonment of a sitting Head of State,"
  • the District Court misinterpreted the TVPA by reliance on inconclusive legislative history in lieu of plain statutory text.
  • the District Court further stumbled by neglecting the constitutional foreign policy prerogatives of Congress under Article I, Section 8, Clause 10 to sanction violations of the law of nations at variance with the President’s preferred realpolitik.
As the Court notes, "All issues and arguments must be raised by appellants in the opening brief. The court ordinarily will not consider issues and arguments raised for the first time in the reply brief."

The briefing schedule indicates that the US Justice Department, if it intends, should file the Amicus Curiae (friend of the court) brief by 8th November, and the appellants should file the reply brief by 23rd November. The Court is then expected to schedule an oral argument.

Chronology:

வியாழன், 4 அக்டோபர், 2012

Opening brief filed in US war-crimes appeal against Rajapakse

Opening brief filed in US war-crimes appeal against Rajapakse

[TamilNet, Thursday, 04 October 2012, 04:20 GMT]
Brief for the three Tamil Plaintiffs-Appellants in the case, Kasippillai Manoharan versus Percy Mahendra Rajpakse, the current sitting Head of Sri Lanka, was filed on Tuesday at the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia, plaintiffs' attorney, Bruce Fein said. The legal issue raised was whether the words "an individual" in the Torture Victims Protection Act (TVPA), Congress subjected to civil liability for complicity in the universal crimes of torture or extra judicial killings under color of foreign law to implement the Convention Against Torture and to advance promoting human rights abroad include the sitting head of states (Mahinda Rajapakse) sued in their individual capacities, the legal brief of the plaintiffs said.

Tamils Against Genocide (TAG), a US-based activist group that seeks legal redress to Tamil war victims, and which initiated the case, said that until all legal avenues are exhausted legal actions against Sri Lanka's high level military and political officials responsible for the Mu'l'livaaykkaal massacre of more than 40,000 unarmed Tamil civilians, the "crime of this century," will continue.

The brief argued that the District Court erred in the following legal issues when rendering the earlier ruling dismissing the case:
  • the Court "erred in conceiving Customary International Law (CIL) as including discretionary as opposed to obligatory rules and by slighting the Convention Against Torture and the Rome Statute in determining whether CIL has evolved since the TVPA to permit civil suits against sitting heads of state for the universal crimes of torture and extrajudicial killing which do not paralyze a foreign government as would a criminal arrest or imprisonment of a sitting Head of State,"
  • the District Court misinterpreted the TVPA by reliance on inconclusive legislative history in lieu of plain statutory text.
  • the District Court further stumbled by neglecting the constitutional foreign policy prerogatives of Congress under Article I, Section 8, Clause 10 to sanction violations of the law of nations at variance with the President’s preferred realpolitik.
rajapakse
Plaintiffs argued that contrary to the District Court, CIL does not recognize limitless executive discretion to grant or withhold sitting Head of State Immunity. By definition, CIL is obligatory, not optional.

The brief also argued further that, to sustain the President’s unfettered discretion to extinguish a TVPA claim against a sitting head of state to advance the Presidents’ foreign policy would effect an unconstitutional taking of property without just compensation under the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.

The Plaintiffs also pointed out athat District Court’s conclusion that Executive Branch prescriptions of sitting Head of State Immunity are binding on the Judiciary in Article III cases and controversies conflicts with the Supreme Court’s rationale in United States v. Klein, 80 U.S. 128 (1871) that rules of decision for federal courts may not be prescribed by the political branches.

In sum, the legal brief said, all relevant canons of statutory construction militate in favor of the TVPA’s application to sitting heads of state complicit in the universal crimes of torture or extrajudicial killings under color of foreign law to further Congressional human rights objectives abroad.

The complaint filed first in 2011 at the District Court for this case alleged multiple violations of the TVPA) based on Sri Lanka's President Rajapaksa’s command responsibility for the extrajudicial killings of Ragihar Manoharan, the son of Plaintiff Dr. Kasippillai Manoharan, of Premas Anandarajah, a humanitarian aid worker for Action Against Hunger, and husband of Plaintiff Kalaiselvi Lavan, and four members of the Thevarajah family, all relatives of Plaintiff Jeyakumar Aiyathurai.

The case was dismissed in February 2012 by Judge Kotelly after the U.S. State Department intervened to assert that, as a sitting head of state, Rajapakse was immune from litigation.

Chronology:

வியாழன், 27 செப்டம்பர், 2012

US letter urges soft approach to Rajapakse rights violations

US letter urges soft approach to Rajapakse rights violations

[TamilNet, Wednesday, 26 September 2012, 02:15 GMT]
Thirty one U.S. Congresspersons on the closing sessions before the US elections in a letter to the Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton, urged her and her collegues to "purposefully and dynamically engage with the Government of Sri Lanka in advancing reconciliation and accountability and a return to peaceful stability." While Tamil diaspora widely regard the Assistant Secretary for South and Central Asian Affairs, Robert O. Blake, as the chief architect for the Sri Lanka policy which resulted in the Mu'l'livaaykaal massacre, the soft approach adopted by the Congresspersons calling for reconciliation, and subtly dropping "International" from Independent investigations, has brought criticism over giving Rajapakse's further space to avoid scrutiny for the alleged perpetration of international crimes on Tamil civilians.

The letter, however, points to the Senate Resolution 84 passed in 2011 which called for Independent International Investigations into "reports of war crimes and crimes against humanity committed by both sides during the war."

"The findings and recommendations of such investigations are meaningless if they result in hollow rhetoric and empty promises that fail to move the reconciliation process forward in Sri Lanka," the letter adds, emphasizing reconciliation.

The letter also notes that "[t]hus far, there is no indication that the UNHRC resolution has had any significant impact on the Sri Lankan government' response to the issue," and cautions that without "strong oversight from the State Department," it will be easy for the Rajapaksa administration to "make excuses for failing to adhere to its obligations [in the UNHRC resolution] during the March 2013 session.