war-crimes லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி
war-crimes லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி

வியாழன், 19 செப்டம்பர், 2013

Politicization of war-crimes: Bashir and Rajapakse

Politicization of war-crimes: Bashir and Rajapakse

[TamilNet, Thursday, 19 September 2013, 10:58 GMT]
While Sri Lanka's President Mahinda Rajapaksa, under whose command responsibility the Sri Lanka military killed nearly UN-estimated 100,000 Tamil civilians, is attending the 62nd United Nations General Assembly, commencing on September 25, the White House is not commenting on if the US would be issuing an entry visa to alleged war-criminal and Sudan's long time leader Hassan al-Bashir to attend the UN annual meeting. Recently, the US State Department, using its discretionary powers, intervened to save Rajapakse from war-crimes charges in Court cases filed by affected Tamils.

“We have an obligation as host nation for the U.N.,” State Department spokeswoman Marie Harf said, referring to the general practice of allowing foreign leaders and diplomats entry to the United States for U.N. business. “I’m just not going to speculate what action we may or may not take other than to say we act consistent with our relevant international obligation,” the Washington Post reported.

U.N. Ambassador Samantha Power started a diplomatic shoving match Monday when she said the United States had received a request for an entry visa from Sudanese President Omar Hassan al-Bashir. It would be “deplorable, cynical and hugely inappropriate” for Bashir to attend the U.N. gathering, Power said, according to the paper.

A spokesperson for US-based activist organization, Tamils Against Genocide (TAG), commenting on the issue said, "The State Department's silence on whether it will allow genocide-indicted Sudanese leader al-Bashir an entry visa is symptomatic of customary American dualistic approaches to human rights enforcement. The question of whether or not al-Bashir should be permitted to attend on American soil is a Red Herring. It obfuscates the question of American intent to enforce international criminal prohibitions on genocide, and its obligation as a UN member to extradite al-Bashir to the Hague if he were present on American territory. If the recurrent presence of Mahinda Rajapakse on American soil during and after the Tamil killing field in Mu'l'livaaykkaal is a precedent, President al-Bashir should not be alarmed by the paroxysm of public discussion."

Sudan’s Foreign Ministry commenting on the US stance, said, the United States is not qualified “to offer sermons and advice” on human rights or international law, in particular because Washington is not a member of the international court and considers itself independent of the court’s decisions. Bashir should be quickly granted a visa to visit New York, the government in Khartoum said.

Professor Boyle, an expert in international law earlier said, "[Samantha] Power stood by and watched 150,000 Tamils be exterminated by the GOSL and did nothing to stop it that I am aware of," and pointing out Power's conspicuous silence during the killing of Tamil civilians reaching genocidal proportions by the Sri Lanka military, said that Power now [at the UN] has a chance to "redeem" herself by establishing an International Criminal Tribunal for Sri Lanka, as did her predecessor Madeline Albright to the former Yugoslavia.

Related Articles:
20.07.13   Can Power, silent on Sri Lanka genocide, redeem herself in U..
06.06.13   Spectators to Sri Lanka genocide ascend in Obama's inner cir..
31.03.13   ICC's focus on Africa examined
31.03.13   Rajapakse immune from war crime charges while in office, rul..
22.03.13   Genocidal double talk by India, US - Prof. Boyle
09.03.13   U.S. judges, Fein in oral legal battle over war-crimes immun..
08.03.13   US UNHRC inaction not inconsistent with saving Rajapakse in ..
22.02.13   Blake, architect of Tamil tragedy, spectator to genocide
08.12.12   Fein: U.S.'s immunity determinations flout due process
01.12.12   Rice's silence on Sri Lanka may hurt cabinet appointment - p..
09.11.12   U.S. reasserts immunity to Rajapakse from war crimes
29.04.12   Samantha Power to chair US genocide prevention effort


External Links:
WP: State Department mum on entry visa for Sudanese president to attend U.N. meeting

வெள்ளி, 15 மார்ச், 2013

U.S. Congressman calls for International Investigation into war-crimes

U.S. Congressman calls for International Investigation into war-crimes

[TamilNet, Friday, 15 March 2013, 01:13 GMT]
U.S. Rep. Eliot Engel (D-NY), the top Democrat on the House Foreign Affairs Committee, in a letter to Secretary Kerry on Wednesday, expressed serious concern regarding the deterioration of democracy and the lack of progress on reconciliation and accountability in Sri Lanka, and added that "now is the time for the State Department to support calls for an Independent International Investigation into allegations of war crimes in Sri Lanka." The Congressman's call answers those who argue among Tamils that the tabled resolution already has provisions for international investigation.

The full text of the Congressman's letter follows:

Dear Secretary Kerry:
U.S. Rep. Eliot Engel (D-NY)
U.S. Rep. Eliot Engel (D-NY)
I am writing to express my concern about the continued erosion of democracy in Sri Lanka and to urge you to call for an independent international investigation into allegations of war crimes by both the Government of Sri Lanka and the terrorist group, the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE), during their final battles.

In the spring of 2009, when the Sri Lankan government defeated the LTTE, many believed the victory would pave the way not only for reconciliation between Sri Lanka’s ethnic groups, but also for a strengthened democracy and greater economic development. But the government has not built upon the peace dividend. Instead, it has used the space to consolidate its power, and to remove some of the checks and balances that are the hallmarks of true democracy. Four years later, rule of law is endangered, media freedom and freedom of speech are under attack, and reconciliation seems even more distant than it did during the long years of conflict.

While certainly the government should be applauded for some of its efforts at rehabilitation and reconstruction in the northern parts of the country, it has made little real progress in addressing the conflict’s underlying issues, or in answering questions of accountability that must be addressed in order to achieve lasting reconciliation and peace in the country.

In fact, the Government’s post-war actions in this direction have all been significantly influenced by the international community. One such example: in May 2010, the government established a Lessons Learnt and Reconciliation Commission (LLRC), partly in response to international pressure over the deaths of an estimated 40,000 civilians at the war’s conclusion. The Sri Lankan Government presented the LLRC as evidence of its commitment to accountability, and argued that the LLRC review precluded the need for other processes on an international level. However, the LLRC had a limited mandate: it examined only the period 2002-2009 and had unclear investigative powers. Critics said it was neither transparent nor impartial.

Nonetheless, even the flawed process of the LLRC review acknowledged important events and grievances that have contributed to decades of political violence and civil war in Sri Lanka. The final LLRC report makes constructive recommendations on a wide range of issues, including the need to credibly investigate widespread allegations of extrajudicial killings and enforced disappearances; demilitarization of the north and the country as a whole; the importance of a political settlement for minorities, with meaningful devolution of power; the protection of the right to freedom of expression for all, including the enactment of a right to information law; and the enactment of rule of law reforms. The report also acknowledged the disproportionate impact of the conflict and its aftermath on women and children.

I commend the leading role the State Department played last March with the passage of the UN Human Rights Council Resolution calling for the Government of Sri Lanka to implement the LLRC’s recommendations. Unfortunately, almost a year has gone by since that resolution passed and the Government has failed to take it up. Its National Action Plan addresses less than a third of the LLRC recommendations, a fact conveniently left out of government responses to international criticism.

The lack of accountability in this instance sets a dangerous pattern, in fact, for the country as a whole. The deterioration of democracy in Sri Lanka includes a 2010 amendment to Sri Lanka’s constitution, hurriedly passed by its Parliament, that removed the two-term limit for the President, provided him legal immunity, and gave him the final say in appointments to the civil service, the judiciary, and the police. Urban Development now comes under the Defence Ministry. And earlier this year, Parliament impeached Chief Justice Shirani Bandaranayake, even though the Supreme Court had deemed that move unconstitutional.

As Assistant Secretary of State for South and Central Asia Robert O. Blake has said, “International mechanisms can become appropriate in cases where states are either unable or unwilling to meet their obligations.” The State Department’s April 2012 report to Congress on Sri Lanka acknowledged that no one has been held to account since the publication of the LLRC. In February, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights issued a strong report questioning the government’s commitment to follow through on the recommendations of the LLRC and urged Sri Lankan authorities to permit international experts to probe allegations of serious human rights violations. I agree with the Commissioner. It is time the U.S. join the call for an independent international investigation.

Secretary Kerry, in a report issued by your staff during your tenure as chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, the authors wrote that the war in Sri Lanka was over, but that the underlying conflict still simmered. Unfortunately, this remains true. I look forward to working with you and the Department to support efforts to address these underlying conflicts.

Sincerely,

Eliot L. Engel

சனி, 9 மார்ச், 2013

U.S. judges, Fein in oral legal battle

U.S. judges, Fein in oral legal battle over war-crimes immunity

[TamilNet, Saturday, 09 March 2013, 00:35 GMT]
United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia circuit judges, Friday 10:00 a.m., engaged with Tamil plaintiffs' attorney in what appeared as an intense and gripping legal battle to decide whether the "Head of State Immunity," as presumed to apply under U.S. Common Law, is trumped by the narrowly tailored Torture Victims Protection Act (TVPA), a statute that allows victims to bring a legal action on "an individual" who committed torture and/or extrajudicial killing in the Manoharan et al v. Rajapakse appeal. United States Department of Justice (DoJ) attorney argued suggesting immunity for Sri Lanka's President Rajapakse, and Patton Boggs, a D.C. Law firm representing Rajapakse, played a minor supplementary role to DoJ attorneys, in filing legal motions, and in the oral argument.
Judge Merrick Garland
Judge Merrick Garland
Judge Brett Kavanaugh
Judge Brett Kavanaugh
Judge Janice Brown
Judge Janice Brown
The Appellate judges Merrick Garland and Brett Kavanaugh, and the generally silent Judge Janice Brown, allowed Plaintiff-Appellant attorney Bruce Fein to continue for nearly 25 minutes exceeding the allotted time of 10 minutes in the back and forth exchange on the legal applicability of "Head of State immunity" to Rajapakse crimes.

Judges Garland and Kavanaugh leaned heavily on the Supreme Court opinion on Samantar (Samantar v. Yousuf, 130 S. Ct. 2278 (2010)) to argue that the frame work for guiding the Federal Appeals courts such as theirs was based on the dicta from the Supreme Court on the Samantar case.

The following are the two pertinent notes from the Samantar US Supreme Court opinion on which the Judges questions were focused:
    ...Under the common-law doctrine of foreign sovereign immunity, see Schooner Exchange v. McFaddon, 7 Cranch 116, if the State De-partment granted a sovereign’s diplomatic request for a “suggestion of immunity,” the district court surrendered its jurisdiction...

    ...when a statute covers an issue previously governed by the common law, we interpret the statute with the presumption that Congress intended to retain the substance of the common law...

    Judges referred to the "the Defense's contention that the District Court correctly concluded that Congress demonstrated no intent to abrogate nearly two centuries of common law head of state immunity jurisprudence."
Fein, argued that the Congress was very aware of the foreign policy implications of including "Head of States" in being accountable for the narrowly tailored TVPA which refers to torture and extra-judicial killings, and that this was not a sweeping exception to the common law which allowed State Department to intervene in Head of State matters of other types of crimes.

Fein also clarified that the "nearly two centuries of common law immunity," was not strictly correct, and that while the ATCA [Alien Tort Claims Act] is part of the Judiciary Act of 1789, only Filártiga v. Peña-Irala in 1980 offered a new conceptualization of the ATCA, ruling that the statute fell within federal-question jurisdiction and hence allowed cause of action arising from the Statute.

Mitchel Berger of Patton Boggs began the Defendant-Appellee Rajapakse side argument for the allocated 5-minutes. The Judges, in mid-stream, advised that since Mr Berger was drawing on the U.S. Government's discretionary intervention to suggest immunity, acceding his time to the U.S. Government attorney would be more efficient and Mr Berger obliged.

Adam C. Jed, a Yale graduate who studied law at Harvard, and won a Gates Scholarship to study mathematics in Cambridge, UK, then argued for the U.S. Government. Mr. Jed said that the local common law is settled on the Head of State immunity when suggested by the State Department, and asked if the judges had questions on U.S.'s legal position.

Attorneys Adam Butschek and Mark Potkewitz assisted in preparing for the legal argument for the Tamil plaintiffs, Fein said.

Mr Potkewitz commented at the end of the oral argument that the judges appeared averse to go against the U.S. Government and are not likely to extend the exception to the Samantar dicta, and that Judge Garland's suggestion during the argument, that legal decision to add an exception to the common law immunity for international crimes, perhaps, rests with the Supreme Court, indicates where the Court is headed," Potkewitz said.

"We intend to start working immediately on the Writ of Certiorari to the Supreme Court of the United States," Potkewitz said.

Chronology:


External Links:
LAWFARE: TVPA Lawsuit Against Sri Lanka President Dismissed, after Administration Submits Delayed Suggestion of Immunity

வெள்ளி, 23 நவம்பர், 2012

Appellants granted time extention in Rajapakse war-crimes case

Appellants granted time extention in Rajapakse war-crimes case

[TamilNet, Thursday, 22 November 2012, 15:41 GMT]
The United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit granted appellants’ motion for extension of time to file the Reply brief, by two weeks, in the appeal case against Sri Lanka's President Mahinda Rajapakse for civil damages on war-crimes charges, according to the court docket. The revised briefing schedule indicated that the Appellant's Reply brief will now have to be filed by December 7, 2012. Attorney for the Appellants, Bruce Fein, told the court that the the intervening holidays and his case work load had necessitated the request for extension and the Court granted his motion.

The Appellant attorney affirmed that "[t]he motion has not been filed for the purpose of delay or other improper purpose. Federal Rules of Civil Procedure (FRCP)-11 (c)(1) allows the Court to impose sanctions on the attorney or law firm if the court determines that the motion is "being presented for an improper purpose, such as to harass, cause unnecessary delay, or needlessly increase the cost of litigation."

The case filed by three Tamil plaintiffs is on appeal from a final order dismissing the complaint for lack of jurisdiction based on a suggestion of immunity for Rajapakse filed by the Department of Justice on behalf of the Department of State.

The complaint was filed first in 2011 at the District Court for this case alleged multiple violations of the Torture Victims Protection Act (TVPA) based on Sri Lanka's President Rajapaksa’s command responsibility for the extrajudicial killings of Ragihar Manoharan, the son of Plaintiff Dr. Kasippillai Manoharan, of Premas Anandarajah, a humanitarian aid worker for Action Against Hunger, and husband of Plaintiff Kalaiselvi Lavan, and four members of the Thevarajah family, all relatives of Plaintiff Jeyakumar Aiyathurai.

Chronology:

திங்கள், 30 ஜனவரி, 2012

US's dissonant positions boon to Sri Lanka's war-criminals

US's dissonant positions boon to Sri Lanka's war-criminals

[TamilNet, Sunday, 29 January 2012, 00:39 GMT]
While several members of the legislative branch of the US Government are pressing for independent international investigations into Sri Lanka's war-crimes, the US executive branch, despite the presence of ardent advocates of human rights as President Obama's group of advisers, guided by Ambassador Robert Blake architected policy that has wrought havoc to Tamil justice, appears to support white-washing of war-crimes, Tamil circles in the US said. Civil society groups in Sri Lanka, which met visiting US officials recently have also reported hearing a Rajapakse-centric position from the officials, and revealed that the officials have tried to persuade the civil society to engage with the Sri Lanka Government on development and reconciliation, and thereby, to remain opposed to Tamil diaspora activities, civil society sources in Jaffna said.

United States Senate resolution S. Res. 84 introduced by Senator Casey and passed in March 2011, called "on the Government of Sri Lanka, the international community, and the United Nations to establish an independent international accountability mechanism to look into reports of war crimes, crimes against humanity, and other human rights violations committed by both sides during and after the war in Sri Lanka and to make recommendations regarding accountability," as one of the four elements of the resolution.

PDF IconLetter to Clinton from 58 Senators
In August 2010, 58 US law makers in a letter to Secretary Clinton urged the Obama administration to call for an independent international investigation into alleged war crimes that occurred during Sri Lanka's civil war.

Further, three senior Senators in a communication to Clinton in November 2011, a few days before the LLRC report was released, said, "if the LLRC fails to meet the basic standards of credibility and independence that the United States has set forth, and the Sri Lankan government does not take steps to hold accountable those persons most responsible for War crimes on both sides of the conflict, We urge you to promptly press for an independent international accountability mechanism."

Robert O'Blake, Former Ambassador to Sri Lanka
Robert O'Blake, Former Ambassador to Sri Lanka
Hillary Rodham Clinton, U.S. Secretary of State
Hillary Rodham Clinton, U.S. Secretary of State
Senator Casey (D-Pennsylvania)
Senator Casey (D-Pennsylvania)
In contrast, executive branch officials have routinely intimated simple solutions based on collaboration with Colombo to resolve chronic issues plaguing the Tamils in NorthEast, reflecting poor understanding of the conflict which has deep roots in decades of oppression, civil society sources in Jaffna said.

Recently four officials from the US Executive branch visited Sri Lanka and Jaffna. The officials, while addressing civil society groups and senior citizens in Jaffna, have reportedly conveyed the following sentiments, which observers noted, were indirectly aimed to turn the NorthEast Tamils against Tamil diaspora.
  • US will not make any reference to UN Panel report or International inquiry at the HRC meeting in March. Possibililty of a resolution against Sri Lanka is remote;
  • Positive aspects of LLRC report will be emphasized and US State Department will be satisfied if Sri Lanka takes measures to implement the recommendations;
  • Solutions to Tamil issues are internal and there will be no outside intervention; and
  • The State Department is not interested in instituting any accountability mechanism.
Statements from Ambassador Blake and the current US Ambassador in Sri Lanka, Ambassador Butenis, exposed by Wikileaks, have established prima facie evidence that the US diplomats knew of Sri Lanka high level officials' complicity to war crimes:
Senator Patrick Leahy, current chairman of the Judiciary Committee
Senator Patrick Leahy, current chairman of the Judiciary Committee
District Court Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly
District Court Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly
However, the seriousness of Sri Lanka's crimes and the numbers of Tamil civilians killed by State action have yet to convince US diplomats to take a stand against the perpetrators of the crimes, say Rights Groups including Human Rights Watch.

Further, knowledge of such evidence, and the documented acts to derail the peace process by Ambassador Blake may even fall into the realm of complicity to Crimes Against Peace, a criminal offense under international law, active Tamil diaspora sources said.

While "tension" prevails between the two branches of the US Government on Sri Lanka's war-crimes, the US State Department has made matters worse by pro-actively intervening on behalf of Sri Lanka's President in the judicial proceedings against Rajapakse. The State Department has sought to preempt the "checks and balances" provided by the third branch of the US Government, the judiciary, by "suggesting" immunity over war-crimes, and asking the judge to dismiss the war-crimes charges against Rajapakse without judicial review, according to legal sources in Washington.

Commenting on the intervention of the State Department in the war-crimes case against Rajapakse, the attorney for the plaintiffs noted, "among other deficiencies in the US Government's legal analysis, we underscored the counter-constitutional proposition asserted by the Executive Branch that it was crowned with judicial power to order the dismissal of lawsuits based on its understanding of the law which federal judges were precluded from second-guessing. Such a putative power in the Executive Branch would blatantly flout the separation of powers enshrined in the Constitution."

Commenting on US's conflicting stand on the issue of Sri Lanka's war crimes, spokesperson for Tamils Against Genocide (TAG), a US-based activist group, said "Increasingly, US-Sri Lanka foreign policy on the matter of Tamil justice appears to comport with the broader post-9/11 American geostrategy of supporting the suspension of human rights and humanitarian law protections in all operative counter-terrorism combat spaces, from Iraq to Afghanistan to Sri Lanka. In each case, the premise of this policy has been the same: the US ultimately monopolizes control over whether a transitional justice mechanism shall emerge in a particular country, a power it seems to wield according to its national interests rather than the interests of justice. The Tamil Diaspora, has a historic responsibility and is uniquely situated to organize to support and deliver Tamil justice in the face of opposition by countervailing national interests, such as those of Sri Lanka or America," TAG spokesperson added.

Related Articles:
15.01.12   Executive overreach to provide immunity to Universal crimes ..
14.01.12   Four US Government officials to visit Sri Lanka
24.11.11   Senators urge US to take lead role in Sri Lanka investigatio..
02.11.11   Shavendra raises immunity defense to escape torture charges
03.03.11   US Senate Resolution calls for accountability for Sri Lanka ..
20.01.11   Congressman renews call for international investigations int..
22.12.10   Forced prostitution, sex slavery with GoSL complicity – US c..
11.08.10   Sri Lanka's Commission convenes as US calls for independent ..


External Links:
USGov: US Cabinet: 15 Depts Established under Article II, Section 2 of the Constitution     

வியாழன், 3 நவம்பர், 2011

Shavendra raises immunity defense to escape torture charges

Shavendra raises immunity defense to escape torture charges

[TamilNet, Wednesday, 02 November 2011, 01:57 GMT]
Sri Lanka's Acting Permanent Representative to the United Nations, and ex-Major General in Sri Lankan Army (SLA), Shavendra Silva, has invoked Article-31 of the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Immunity as his defense to war-crimes charges leveled against him by two Tamil plaintiffs in the District Court of Southern District of New York (Case 11 Civ. 6645), court records show. With no declared formal intervention by the U.S. State Department, and despite earlier pronouncements that Silva will defend his actions in the Court of law, the ex-General appears to have thought it prudent to hide behind "absolute" immunity defense his counsel claims the General is legally entitled to.

Silva's counsel mentions in a letter to the Court that filing an official Motion to Dismiss will "dignify the alleged attempts at "service" on the Ambassador," and therefore, they were requesting their letter to be treated as a motion to dismiss, which the Court granted.

The Plaintiffs are expected to file a reply to the motion to dismiss by the 8th of November, and Defendant's reply, if any, to be filed before the 17th November.

Shavendra Silva, alleged War Criminal holding UN post
Shavendra Silva, alleged War Criminal holding UN post
The defense argues that pursuant to a UN Convention on Privileges and Immunities, and to an agreement UN and the US regarding the Head Quarters located in New York, Mr Silva has the same Immunities accorded to diplomats, and that Mr Silva is entitled to such immunity as defined by the Vienna Convention.

The defense also argues that such immunity is "absolute," and therefore, precludes any civil action from proceeding against a currently-serving diplomat, regardless of the nature of the alleged crimes.

The defense cites four previous cases in support of its immunity argument.

While the question of immunity is a difficult hurdle to overcome, the defense's argument is clearly less than persuasive. First, there are no binding Supreme Court cases cited by the defense on the issue of immunity. The second circuit case cited involves functional immunity, and can be distinguished from Shavendra case where the issue is one of crimes against humanity committed while the defendant was not a diplomat, and no functional immunity applies here, legal sources in Washington said.

Further, courts have said the purpose of the immunity "is not to benefit individuals but to ensure efficient performance of the functions of diplomatic missions." In Shavendra's case, the likely argument presented by the plaintiffs is, Colombo purportedly sought to exploit the immunity provision to sanitize an alleged war-criminal. Plaintiffs are likely to highlight Switzerland's warning to ex-General Jagath Dias on imminent war-crimes investigations, and Colombo recalling the General, as an appropriate example of Colombo's efforts to send alleged criminals as diplomats, legal sources added.

"Legal scholars have argued that diplomatic immunity, which supports personal inviolability, may not prevail when the defendant has committed international crimes. When establishing the hierarchy between norms granting immunity and norms protecting fundamental values such as human life, the immunity norms always lose. Further, diplomatic immunity is a functionality based principle based on "reciprocal compromise," and cannot be categorized as jus cogens, or compelling law. U.S. jurisprudence will inevitably move towards a position where sanitization of genocidaires, such as Shavendra Silva, is legally prevented by narrowly interpreting the doctrine of immunity," spokesperson for the US-based activist group, Tamils Against Genocide (TAG), said.

Ali Beydoun, lead counsel and director at American University's Human Rights Impact Litigation Clinic, filed the civil action against Mr Silva on behalf of Tamil plaintiffs Vathsala Devi and Seetharam Sivam.

Chronology:


Related Articles:
19.10.11   Rajapakse says will defy Court Order, Shavendra hires NY law..