US court லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி
US court லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி

திங்கள், 1 ஏப்ரல், 2013

Rajapakse immune from war crime charges

Rajapakse immune from war crime charges while in office, rules US Court

[TamilNet, Sunday, 31 March 2013, 12:04 GMT]
United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia circuit in the opinion delivered this week on the appeal case against Sri Lanka's President Rajpakse filed by three Tamil plaintiffs claiming civil damages on war-crimes charges ruled that "as a consequence of the [U.S.] State Department’s suggestion of immunity, the defendant [Rajapakse] is entitled to head of state immunity under the common law while he remains in office...," and affirmed the judgment of the district court dismissing the plaintiffs’ complaint. The plaintiffs' attorney Bruce Fein told TamilNet that he will advise his clients and the sponsoring organization if they should consider filing a writ of certiorari keep the option open to move the case further forward to the Supreme Court.

The oral argument was heard by a three-judge court consisting of Judges Merrick Garland, Janice Brown, and Brett Kavanaugh.
The Court said that the Common Law relevant to the issue of immunity is established, and that “the diplomatic representative of the sovereign could request a ‘suggestion of immunity’ from the State Department,” and “[i]f the request was granted, the district court surrendered its jurisdiction.
Dr Kasippillai Manoharan
Dr Kasippillai Manoharan
Bruce Fein, former US Associate Deputy Attorney General
Bruce Fein, former US Associate Deputy Attorney General
The Court said that, therefore, it has no jurisdiction unless Congress intended the TVPA [Torture Victims Protection Act] to supersede the common law which governs the issue for the case at bar, as the court recognized that “The canon of construction that statutes should be interpreted consistently with the common law helps us interpret a statute that,” as here, “clearly covers a field formerly governed by the common law.

The court then considered "the language of the TVPA," to interpret if the Congress intended "torture," a crime accepted as a universal crime under international law, as a narrow exception to granting immunity to "an individual" including head of states.

The court said,"...plaintiffs contend supersedes the common law because it renders “an individual” liable for damages in a civil action, and a head of state is “an individual.” But as even the plaintiffs acknowledge, the term “an individual” cannot be read to cover every individual; plaintiffs agree that both diplomats and visiting heads of state retain immunity when they visit the United States.

Referring to an analogous statute the court concluded that "Congress did not intend that language to abrogate the preexisting common law of immunity applicable to executive officials," and "that the common law of head of state immunity survived enactment of the TVPA."

The spokesperson for the US-based activist group, Tamils Against Genocide [TAG] which seeks judicial redress for Tamil victims of war including sponsoring this case, commented: "Under contemporary norms of international human rights, head of States are not entitled to immunity for jus cogens norms violations. The appellate court's interpretation of common law immunity doctrine is incompatible with the universally recognized prohibitions of torture and crimes against humanity. If the ruling stands, the State Department's intervention to save Rajapakse symbolizes the human rights double standard at the center of the Obama administration's foreign policy, preaching its inviolability abroad, while pardoning it at home, in America's own courts," TAG said of the decision.

The complaint was filed first in 2011 at the District Court for this case alleged multiple violations of the Torture Victims Protection Act (TVPA) based on Sri Lanka's President Rajapaksa’s command responsibility for the extrajudicial killings of Ragihar Manoharan, the son of Plaintiff Dr. Kasippillai Manoharan, of Premas Anandarajah, a humanitarian aid worker for Action Against Hunger, and husband of Plaintiff Kalaiselvi Lavan, and four members of the Thevarajah family, all relatives of Plaintiff Jeyakumar Aiyathurai.

After the intervention of the U.S. Justice Department which "suggested" Head of State immunity, the trial court dismissed the case. The plaintiffs appealed.

Related Articles:
09.03.13   U.S. judges, Fein in oral legal battle over war-crimes immun..

சனி, 19 ஜனவரி, 2013

US Court to hear oral argument on Rajpakase war crime case

US Court to hear oral argument on Rajpakase war crime case

[TamilNet, Saturday, 19 January 2013, 02:35 GMT]
United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia circuit has scheduled March 8th, 9:30 am for the oral argument in the appeal case against Sri Lanka's President Mahinda Rajapakse for civil damages on war-crimes charges filed by three Tamil plaintiffs whose relatives were extra-judicially executed or unlawfully killed under the "command responsibility" of Rajapakse. "The key legal issue in this case is whether the U.S.'s Torture Victims Protection Act (TVPA) deputed the Executive Branch with authority to extinguish TVPA claims against sitting heads of state based on professed foreign policy concerns," plaintiff-appellants' attorney, Bruce Fein, said. Judges Merrick Garland, Janice Brown, and Brett Kavanaugh have been assigned to hear the case, according to Court papers.
Defendant-Appellee Rajapakse's counsel from Patton Boggs, a large law firm in Washington D.C. is likely to depend on the United States Justice Department lawyers to save Rajapakse in the legal battle, the motion filed the U.S. Government indicates. "Counsel for the defendant-appellee informs us that he has not yet determined whether he will participate at the argument but that the defendant-appellee will, in any case, cede time to the United States," the U.S. Government motion said in a footnote.

"All U.S. Tamils should attempt to attend the hearing as the case symbolizes the urgent need to hold President Rajapakse accountable for his despicable and criminal acts under international law. The case is at the frontiers of the human rights law, and we are guardedly optimistic that independent federal judges will not permit President Rajapaksa’s international crimes to evade justice," Fein told TamilNet.

"The U.S. Government has affirmatively exercised its discretionary option, first in the trial court, and now in the appellate court, to intervene to save Rajapakse from legal action by legitimate victims of his allegedly murderous conduct. Ambassador Blake architected policy of appeasing Sri Lanka overlooking the killing more than 80,000 Tamil civilians in Mu'l'livaaykkaal, appears to have even trumped Sri Lanka's continued dismissal of the chorus of disapproval from the West on autocracy-leaning governance matters in Colombo," a spokesperson for Tamils Against Genocide (TAG), a US-based activist group, said.
Judge Merrick Garland
Judge Merrick Garland
Judge Janice Brown
Judge Janice Brown
Judge Brett Kavanaugh
Judge Brett Kavanaugh
Two of the judges, Brown and Kavanaugh, were appointed by Republican President, George Bush, and Judge Garland was appointed by President Bill Clinton, a Democrat.

Merrick Brian Garland (born November 13, 1952) was widely seen as a leading contender for a nomination to the Supreme Court in the Obama administration following the announced retirement of Justice John Paul Stevens. On September 6, 1995, President Bill Clinton nominated Garland to the D.C. Circuit.

Garland was touted as a possible successor to retiring Supreme Court Justice Paul Stevens. Before taking a seat as a U.S. Circuit Court judge, Garland was a respected Justice Department official who supervised the investigation of the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing and prosecution of the Unabomber. As a jurist, the Chicago native and graduate of Harvard Law School is considered a centrist. Soft-spoken yet engaging, Garland is said to ask lots of questions.

Janice Rogers Brown (born May 11, 1949) previously was an Associate Justice of the California Supreme Court, holding that post from May 2, 1996 until her appointment to the D.C. Circuit.mPresident George W. Bush nominated her to her current position in 2003.

Brett Michael Kavanaugh (born February 12, 1965) was formerly the Staff Secretary in the Executive Office of the President of the United States under President George W. Bush. Kavanaugh himself was nominated to the D.C. Appeals Court by Bush in 2003.

The complaint was filed first in 2011 at the District Court for this case alleged multiple violations of the Torture Victims Protection Act (TVPA) based on Sri Lanka's President Rajapaksa’s command responsibility for the extrajudicial killings of Ragihar Manoharan, the son of Plaintiff Dr. Kasippillai Manoharan, of Premas Anandarajah, a humanitarian aid worker for Action Against Hunger, and husband of Plaintiff Kalaiselvi Lavan, and four members of the Thevarajah family, all relatives of Plaintiff Jeyakumar Aiyathurai.

Chronology:

சனி, 25 ஆகஸ்ட், 2012

US Court of Appeals to hear Rajapakse war-crimes case

US Court of Appeals to hear Rajapakse war-crimes case

[TamilNet, Friday, 24 August 2012, 03:59 GMT]
United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit issued the briefing schedule Monday for the appeal against the dismissal of the war-crimes case against Sri Lanka's President Mahinda Rajapakse. The appeal was filed by three Tamil plaintiffs/ appellants against Rajapakse for complicity in extrajudicial killings of plaintiffs relatives in violation of the Torture Victims Protection Act (TVPA). The case, first filed at the lower court, was dismissed in February 2012 by Judge Kotelly after the U.S. State Department intervened to assert that, as a sitting head of state, Rajapakse was immune from litigation.

The complaint filed in 2011 at the District Court for this case alleged multiple violations of the TVPA) based on Sri Lanka's President Rajapaksa’s command responsibility for the extrajudicial killings of Ragihar Manoharan, the son of Plaintiff Dr. Kasippillai Manoharan, of Premas Anandarajah, a humanitarian aid worker for Action Against Hunger, and husband of Plaintiff Kalaiselvi Lavan, and four members of the Thevarajah family, all relatives of Plaintiff Jeyakumar Aiyathurai.

The appeal will be heard by a panel of three judges, unless the appellants request and if the court grants an en banc hearing. U.S. State Department has filed a motion to submit an amicus brief (an unsolicited legal opinion provided by a third party to assist the court in deciding the matter) on behalf of the appellee Rajapakse.

Plaintiff/Appellants' attorney, Bruce Fein told TamilNet, "Our opening brief is due October 2, 2012. The opposition brief by Sri Lanka's sitting President Rajapaksa is due November 1, 2012. Oral argument before the U.S. Court of Appeals will probably be held in the early months of 2013.

"We argue that the TVPA applies to "an individual" who perpetrates extrajudicial killings under color of foreign law with no exceptions for sitting heads of state; and, that torture or extrajudicial killings are so morally reprehensible and repugnant to civilized life that no government can authorize the malignity.

"Every Tamil in the United States should seek to attend the oral argument to be held in Washington, D.C., and to protest before the U.S. State Department because of its running to the defense of Rajapaksa on the ground that sitting heads of state are shielded from TVPA suits in the Secretary of State so decrees," Fein said.

Tamils Against Genocide (TAG), a US-based activist organization that seeks judicial redress to victims of war, and which is the sponsor of this case on behalf of the appellants, said in a press release, "Since alleged facts are presumed true at this phase, the appellate challenge to the court's dismissal of charges of crimes against humanity against Rajapakse will test the split in American human rights civil jurisprudence on the issue of whether individuals possess head-of-state immunity or not for jus cogens norm violations as a matter of law.

"The intervention of the State Department in support of Rajapakse's immunity at the trial phase, and the status of the United States as a party to the case at the appellate phase, tend to illuminate the Obama administration's self-contradictory posture on the issue of Tamil justice in post-Mullivaikaal Sri Lanka," TAG said.

Chronology:

சனி, 12 மே, 2012

US Court frees Karunakaran

US Court frees Karunakaran

[TamilNet, Saturday, 12 May 2012, 03:11 GMT]
The District Court of Eastern District Court of New York Friday freed Kandasamy Karunakaran who was arrested five years ago and charged with providing material support to Liberation Tigers designated as a "Foreign Terrorist Organization (FTO)" in the U.S. Judge Raymond Dearie noting that "this is not a garden variety terrorism case," and adding that "[w]e have to pull back that emblazoned banner of terrorism and look at the case specifically," signaled a likely softening of zealous prosecution of material support to organizations that has a history of resisting oppressive States accused of committing genocide.

A U.S. prosecutor argued Friday that as the top US representative for the Tamil Tigers, Karunakaran deserved the maximum 20 years for raising money for a separatist group that earned the State Department's terrorist designation.

In the letter submitted to the Court during sentencing, Karunakaran's attorney Ross said, Karunakaran "grew up in and was directly affected by the brutal regime in Sri Lanka and it is clear that his actions, while not excusable, were motivated by a deeply felt desire to help the community he loved.

Ross added his client, who had been given asylum in the US in 1980, belonged to an ethnic community that had been targeted for years for genocide by Sri Lanka's ethnic majority.

"I simply want to express my remorse," Karunakaran told the judge before he was sentenced. "I was raised in a country where my family lived in constant fear. My intent was only to help my people."

Karunakaran and others were tied to a covert campaign to raise and launder millions of dollars through a charity front organization. Prosecutors had accused him of personally raising millions of dollars for the Tamil Tigers, and that he went to Sri Lanka to meet with rebel commanders, AP reported.

"But Dearie said it was a stretch to say the former cab driver had a leadership role, and that he believed Karunakaran was involved in humanitarian - not military - aid for Sri Lanka's Tamil minority," AP added.

Judge Dearie's decision follows the release of another high-profile Tamil, Dr Murugesu Vinayagamoorthy, a British doctor who was incarcerated on material support charges after serving nearly four years in remand.

A former University of Waterloo student, Ramanan Mylvaganam, has also pleaded guilty in the New York district court on material support charges and waiting sentencing hearing Monday (14th May).

Legal sources in Washington said the precedent setting Karunakaran case may augur well for Mylvaganam receiving a light sentence from Judge Dearie who, legal sources add, has grasped the context of Sri Lanka civil war surprisingly well and has probed deeply the prosecution attorneys on Sri Lanka's complicity in crimes against Tamils.

ஞாயிறு, 18 டிசம்பர், 2011

Rajapakse accepts Court summons, asks US to confer immunity

Rajapakse accepts Court summons, asks US to confer immunity

[TamilNet, Saturday, 17 December 2011, 19:35 GMT]
After avoiding service for more than 9 months, and despite statements by Colombo that Sri Lanka's President Mahinda Rajapakse is not answerable to US Courts, Rajapakse-appointed counsel from the lobby firm of Patton Boggs filed a motion with the District Court of District of Columbia for "enlargement of time to respond to the complaint" related to the legal action, 11-cv-00235, by three Tamil plaintiffs sponsored by Tamils Against Genocide (TAG), a US-based activist group. Legal observers expressed surprise at the filing, which, in addition to effecting waiver of service, also attempts to set the time window for response pleading tied to a discretionary act by Judge Kotelly on seeking view of the US State Department.

Bruce Fein, attorney for the plaintiffs, said that the Court will likely reject the defendant's request, and set a time limit for the defendant to answer the complaint. The judge will independently decide if and when to seek views from the State Department, Fein said.

District Court Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly
District Court Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly
Mitchell R. Berger, Partner at Patton Boggs
Mitchell R. Berger, Partner at Patton Boggs
Legal observers said that despite earlier defiance, Rajapaksas may have relented after receiving legal advice from US indicating that failure to respond to the Court summons may result in a default judgement which will likely bar Rajapaksa from entering the US without paying the monetary award if granted by the court.

Spokesperson for Tamils Against Genocide (TAG), said: "This is a landmark development for the expatriate Tamils who are forcing Sri Lanka's President to a neutral court to answer charges of war-crimes. From absolute immunity enjoyed by Heads of State before worldwar II, evolving restricted immunity doctrines within the US's Federal Surveillance and Intelligence Act (FSIA) necessarily demand Rajapakse to present his exculpatory legal or factual arguement to avoid paying damages to the plaintiffs. Tamil lobby groups should work with sympathetic congresspersons to pressure the executive branch not to bail out the perpetrator of dastardly crimes against Tamil civilans," TAG added.

Plaintiff's attorney indicated that once the Court sets a timeline for submission he will review with plaintiffs the legally opportune time to include additional defendants to the case, including Gotabaya Rajapakse.

In addition to seeking the view of the US State Department, Rajapakse filing, even while the verdict on the acceptability of LLRC's work is being debated, disingenuously asserts that "United States Government has endorsed the work of the LLRC in addressing allegations concerning the actions of the combatants during the now-ended conflict" and uses the Assistant Secretary of State, Robert O' Blake's statements as defense to Rajapakse's alleged crimes and the purported US's policy approach to Sri Lanka, legal sources who have studied the Rajapakse motion said.

The future plan of legal defense of Rajapakse as briefly outlined in the Motion includes the following: (a) Court has no personal jurisdiction, (b) Heads of State are absolutely immune from suit in the United States, (c) Senior foreign government officials are entitled to foreign official immunity (d) plaintiffs’ claims raise non-justiciable political question, and (e) U.S. judicial evaluation of alleged sovereign acts within Sri Lanka would violate the Act of State doctrine.

Legal experts said that absent State Department intervention to save Rajapakse, the legal war will center around the restrictive immunity that may arise from the doctrines involving Head of State immunity. "That Patton Boggs would raise Act of State defense for the crimes against humanity alleged against Rajapakse, is unexpected," a legal expert said.

The Complaint by the three Tamil plaintiffs alleges multiple violations of the Torture Victims Protection Act (TVPA) based on Sri Lanka's President Rajapaksa’s command responsibility for the extrajudicial killings of Ragihar Manoharan, the son of Plaintiff Dr. Kasippillai Manoharan, of Premas Anandarajah, a humanitarian aid worker for Action Against Hunger, and husband of Plaintiff Kalaiselvi Lavan, and four members of the Thevarajah family, all relatives of Plaintiff Jeyakumar Aiyathurai.

Chronology:


External Links:
LI: Rajapakse files motion in war crimes case, effectively accepts summons served

புதன், 5 அக்டோபர், 2011

Rajapakse, an enemy of all mankind, filed U.S. Court papers say

Rajapakse, an enemy of all mankind, filed U.S. Court papers say

[TamilNet, Saturday, 01 October 2011, 17:07 GMT]
In a potential precedent setting motion filed in the U.S. District Court of District of Columbia, Bruce Fein, attorney for three Tamil plaintiffs, requested Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly, to authorize issuing summons through latest electronic social networks and local papers to the defendant, Sri Lanka's sitting President, Mahinda Rajapakse, forcing the defendant to answer war-crimes charges, paving the way for Court determination of civil claims of $30m, legal sources in Washington said. Arguing that Rajapakse is "hostis humani generis," an enemy of all mankind, the motion provides legal precedence to establish that Rajapakse's crimes fall under Universal Jurisdiction applicable under TVPA.

Tamils Against Genocide (TAG), the US-based activist group which sponsored the case and has authority to advise the attorney on behalf of the plaintiffs, said, "this is a precedent setting phase forcing the court to determine if it agrees to allow service through social media including news papers on defendants who can duck traditional means of service under the veil of sovereignty.

Mahinda Rajapakse
Bruce Fein, former US Associate Deputy Attorney General
Bruce Fein, former US Associate Deputy Attorney General
"If the court agrees, then Rajpakse's alleged crimes will undergo strict judicial scrutiny in US Courts. Channel-4 video, allegations in UN panel report, and other emerging evidence including those in "White flag" killings will likely be submitted to first determine if they will be legally admissible, and then to establish culpability of the defendant," TAG's spokesperson said.

A press release issued today marking the filing of the motion, said on the alternate service, "[b]asically, it [may mean] the President can be served via the Internet, Facebook and Twitter and email. The President can no longer claim he is unaware of the charges alleged against him.”

Recognizing that the court will not be willing to rule on the motion unless the Court is convinced that the court has personal jurisdiction over the defendant, the motion provides legal reasoning to establish that the forum has personal jurisdiction over Rajapakse. "The law treats the extrajudicial killings alleged in the complaint as universal wrongs against all of mankind that have been constructively perpetrated everywhere in the world, including in the District of Columbia," the motion says at the beginning of the argument.

As Hostii Humani Generis (“Hostii”), TVPA violators are subject to the doctrine of universal jurisdiction. The Senate Judiciary Committee report on the TVPA explicitly states that “[s]tates have the option, under international law, to decide whether they will allow a private right of action in their courts for violations of human rights that take place abroad,” and, “according to the doctrine of universal jurisdiction, the courts of all nations have jurisdiction over ‘offenses of universal interest.’”

Fein, noting that the legal fallouts of the case will have foreign policy implications for the U.S, told TamilNet, "[w]e have filed our motion for alternate service of the TVPA Complaint and Summons on President Rajapaksa. There is a substantial chance United States District Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly will solicit the views of the United States Department of State as to whether the suit should move forward.

"Accordingly, our supporters should begin immediately to lobby the Department and especially Secretary Clinton against interposing any opposition to our TVPA suit resting on extrajudicial killings constituting war crimes and flouting core standards of civilization. Members of Congress should also be lobbied to intercede with the State Department in our favor," Fein said.

"As the civil procedure in war crimes litigation progresses to the service of process stage by publication in a newspaper of general circulation, the filing and advance of the litigation is a watershed moment. Rajapakse is the first Sri Lankan President in Sri Lankan history to be put on trial via a competent judicial body for war crimes and torture targeting Sri Lanka's Tamil community. The concept of accountability for state-sponsored crimes against Tamils through the fair administration of justice is a novel notion in Sri Lanka's legal culture, accustomed to justifying the massacre of civilians and murder of dissidents as self-evident necessities of its national security mandate," TAG said on the filing.

Chronology:


External Links:
DailyMirror: US Court summons MR
GP: Social networkers to subpoena Sri Lankan president for alleged war crimes?
: Mr. President “You Have Been Served”
LS: President Rajapakse likely to be served summons via media in US case, Gota may be added as a defendent
SL: The Jurisdiction Of US Courts To Summon A Foreign Head Of State