War Crimes charges லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி
War Crimes charges லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி

ஞாயிறு, 9 டிசம்பர், 2012

South Africa rejects Silva

South Africa rejects Silva for deputy ambassadorship?

[TamilNet, Saturday, 08 December 2012, 17:59 GMT]
Southern Africa Litigation Centre (SALC), a non-profit group that promotes human rights and rule of law in South Africa, noting that South Africa's President is constitutionally mandated, in terms of section 84(2)(h) of the Constitution, to either receive and recognize foreign diplomats or to decline the sending state’s request, and asserting that "[a]uthoritative and extensive information, including a high-level UN Secretary-General’s report, exists linking General Silva to the commission of war crimes and crimes against humanity during the Sri Lankan civil war," concludes "General Silva [as] ineligible for the nominated diplomatic post," and that South Africa is compelled to refuse to receive and recognize him as such." SALC said it has learnt that "South Africa has declined to receive General Silva, although there is no official confirmation of this."

Shavendra Silva, retired Army General
Shavendra Silva, retired Army General
If the rejection is true, SALC said it applauds South Africa's decision.

"It [the rejection of Shavendra Silva] demonstrates principled observance of South Africa’s commitment to ending impunity for international crimes and respect for human rights worldwide. It also shows that South Africa’s foreign policy subscribes to the belief that the maintenance of political and international relationships will not trump human rights considerations," SALC said in the web posting.

"Informed assessment of General Silva‟s suitability compels the conclusion that he is ineligible to take up an ambassadorial position in South Africa on account of the credible allegations against him that he participated in the commission of war crimes and crimes against humanity in Sri Lanka in 2009," SALC said.

In a legal briefing paper prepared to assist the President and the Department of International Relations and Cooperation (DIRCO) in assessing General Silva’s credentials and in reaching a considered determination, SALC highlights the legal implications of recognizing persons accused of war crimes and discusses the considerations that should inform decisions made in terms of section 84(2)(h), SALC said.

"These are relevant beyond the circumstances of General Silva’s anticipated deployment and it is hoped that the briefing paper will inform future decisions in which the eligibility of diplomatic nominees are assessed, especially in instances where the sending state [Sri Lanka] is one with a questionable human rights record," SALC said in the briefing paper.

The allegations of crimes against humanity and war crimes against General Silva require that the President and DIRCO evaluate his eligibility with reference to two key considerations: the purpose and integrity of diplomatic status and its attendant privileges and South Africa‟s domestic and international obligations to ensure accountability for international crimes, the briefing paper said.

"Were General Silva to be received and recognised as deputy ambassador to South Africa, he would be conferred with diplomatic immunity. The practice of diplomatic immunity is intended to safeguard sovereign equality between states and enable the peaceful conduct of foreign relations. It is not intended to shield individuals from accountability for egregious human rights violations. The extension of diplomatic immunity to General Silva would amount to an abuse of the internationally regulated system of diplomatic status," SALC cautioned.

SALC adds, "[m]oreover, by recognising and receiving General Silva, and in consequence recognising his diplomatic immunity, South Africa would render itself complicit in his impunity, frustrating efforts at accountability and denying justice to the victims of Sri Lanka‟s conflict. In so doing, South Africa would violate its own constitutional, domestic and international obligations."

Extensively quoting from Report of the Secretary General`s Panel of Experts on Accountability in Sri Lanka, the legal brief examined the conduct of Sri Lanka Army (SLA) 58th Division operating under Silva's command was "explicitly linked in the UN Report to several of the most notorious violations of humanitarian law and human rights committed during the conflict."

The brief also said, after the war, "Navi Pillay, also expressed her concern to UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon over General Silva‟s appointment to this special advisory group, and in a letter stated "that there is, at the very least, the appearance of a case of international crimes to answer by Mr. Silva.""

Chronology:


External Links:
SA: Diplomatic Impunity – Why Suspected War Criminals should not be Diplomats


Fein: U.S.'s immunity determinations flout due process

Fein: U.S.'s immunity determinations flout due process

[TamilNet, Saturday, 08 December 2012, 14:43 GMT]
In the final legal brief filed with the United States Court of Appeals in the case against Sri Lanka's President Mahinda Rajapakse for civil damages on war-crimes charges, appellants, Dr Manoharan et al.'s attorney Bruce Fein asserts that "[n]either the Constitution, nor the Torture Victim Protection Act (“TVPA”), nor customary international law (“CIL”) crowns the Executive with exclusive authority to determine whether a sitting head of state is immune from a TVPA suit founded on the grisly and universally abhorred crimes of torture or extrajudicial killing under color of foreign law," and argues that the Court should reject the U.S. State Department's contention that "when the Executive speaks on immunity, the judiciary is ousted of jurisdiction to interpret the law, [and that the] Adjudication of the case moves from Article III courts to the Article II President."

No United States Supreme Court decision supports such a startling usurpation by the Executive of the customary duty of the judiciary to interpret the law under the Constitution’s separation of powers, the brief said, pointing to Chief Justice John Marshall's forceful statement in Marbury v. Madison: “It is emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is."

Rajapakse attorneys legal response, as happened in the proceedings in the lower court, depended entirely on the Department of Justice's reassertion of the "suggestion of immunity," to save Rajpakse from criminal charges resulting in civil damages.

Bruce Fein, former US Associate Deputy Attorney General
Bruce Fein, former US Associate Deputy Attorney General
Mahinda Rajapakse
Mahinda Rajapakse (Photo: AP)
Dr Manoharan's Reply brief provides supporting arguments for the appellant's position that militates against providing immunity to Rajpakse from the alleged universional crimes. The brief focuses on the following five legal issues:
  1. Neither the Constitution, nor the Torture Victim Protection Act (“TVPA”), nor customary international law (“CIL”) crowns the Executive with exclusive authority to determine whether a sitting head of state is immune from a TVPA suit founded on the grisly and universally abhorred crimes of torture or extrajudicial killing under color of foreign law.
  2. The TVPA Creates a Cause of Action Against Sitting Heads of State for the Universal Crimes of Torture or Extrajudicial Killing Under Color of Foreign Law.
  3. Supreme Court foreign sovereign immunity decisions concerning in rem actions against foreign government vessels have been misinterpreted and misapplied to confer sitting head of state immunity for unspeakable extrajudicial killings in violation of CIL.
  4. CIL Rejects the Executive’s Optional Sitting Head of State Immunity Power for TVPA Suits Resting on the Universal Crimes of Torture or Extrajudicial Killing.
  5. Unconstitutional Takings. The Supreme Court indicated in Dames & Moore v. Regan, 453 U.S. 654 (1981), that an executive order of the President that extinguished pending legal claims in federal court required payment of just compensation under the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment.
Attorney Adam Butschek and Mark Potkewitz assisted Bruce Fein acting for the Plaintiffs-Appellants. Tamils Against Genocide [TAG], a US-based activist organization which seeks legal redress for Tamil victims of Sri Lanka's civil war, serves as power of attorney for the plaintiffs and is the sponsor of the litigation.

The complaint was filed first in 2011 at the District Court for this case alleged multiple violations of the Torture Victims Protection Act (TVPA) based on Sri Lanka's President Rajapaksa’s command responsibility for the extrajudicial killings of Ragihar Manoharan, the son of Plaintiff Dr. Kasippillai Manoharan, of Premas Anandarajah, a humanitarian aid worker for Action Against Hunger, and husband of Plaintiff Kalaiselvi Lavan, and four members of the Thevarajah family, all relatives of Plaintiff Jeyakumar Aiyathurai.

Chronology:


சனி, 3 நவம்பர், 2012

Rajapakse depends on U.S. to defend War Crimes charges

Rajapakse depends on U.S. to defend War Crimes charges

[TamilNet, Friday, 02 November 2012, 00:48 GMT]
Sri Lanka's President Mahinda Rajapakse filed his reply brief at the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Thurdsay in response to the opening brief filed by the three Tamil Plaintiffs-Appellants in the case, Kasippillai Manoharan versus Percy Mahendra Rajpakse, attorney for the appellants Bruce Fein said. "Rajapakse attorneys again appear to depend on the Department of Justice of the United States to reassert the "suggestion of immunity" and for the Appeals judges accept, as did the trial court, to defend Rajapakse on the charges of war-crimes," legal sources in Washington said.

The appeal was filed by three Tamils against Rajapakse for complicity in extrajudicial killings of plaintiffs relatives in violation of the Torture Victims Protection Act (TVPA). The case, first filed at the lower court, was dismissed in February 2012 by Judge Kotelly after the U.S. State Department intervened to assert that, as a sitting head of state, Rajapakse was immune from litigation.

Mitchell Berger and Benjamin Wood at the Washington Law firm Patton Boggs LLP, appearing as Counsel for Mahinda Rajapaksa, in the brief, argue that,
    rajapakse
  • Rajapaksa did Not Appear on the Merits in the District Court and Expressly Reserved All Jurisdictional and Other Defenses,
  • The United States’ Suggestion of Immunity Bound the District Court and Divested It of Jurisdiction, and
  • The United States, Expected to Participate as Amicus Curiae, Is the Proper Party to Advocate for Affirmance of the District Court Decision.
In addition to other cases, the Appellee's attorneys cite Belhas v. Moshe Ya’Alon, 515 F.3d 1279, 1287 (D.C. Cir. 2008), that the pre- Samantar holding that TVPA did not eliminate foreign official immunity under the FSIA even for alleged jus cogens violations.

The appellants' had, in the opening brief, argued that District Court erred in the following legal issues when rendering the earlier ruling dismissing the case:
    Bruce Fein, former US Associate Deputy Attorney General
    Bruce Fein, former US Associate Deputy Attorney General
  • the Court "erred in conceiving Customary International Law (CIL) as including discretionary as opposed to obligatory rules and by slighting the Convention Against Torture and the Rome Statute in determining whether CIL has evolved since the TVPA to permit civil suits against sitting heads of state for the universal crimes of torture and extrajudicial killing which do not paralyze a foreign government as would a criminal arrest or imprisonment of a sitting Head of State,"
  • the District Court misinterpreted the TVPA by reliance on inconclusive legislative history in lieu of plain statutory text.
  • the District Court further stumbled by neglecting the constitutional foreign policy prerogatives of Congress under Article I, Section 8, Clause 10 to sanction violations of the law of nations at variance with the President’s preferred realpolitik.
As the Court notes, "All issues and arguments must be raised by appellants in the opening brief. The court ordinarily will not consider issues and arguments raised for the first time in the reply brief."

The briefing schedule indicates that the US Justice Department, if it intends, should file the Amicus Curiae (friend of the court) brief by 8th November, and the appellants should file the reply brief by 23rd November. The Court is then expected to schedule an oral argument.

Chronology: