Boyle லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி
Boyle லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி

புதன், 25 டிசம்பர், 2013

Tamils should guard against from being misled by IC, says Boyle

Tamils should guard against from being misled by IC, says Boyle

[TamilNet, Monday, 23 December 2013, 19:45 GMT]
"Based upon my first-hand personal experiences working with the Palestinians at their peace negotiations and the Bosnians at their peace negotiations, the Tamils cannot trust the United States, the United Kingdom, the United Nations, the European Union and its Member States to do the right thing for them. The Tamils can only trust in themselves,” responded Professor Francis Boyle on Monday, when TamilNet asked him what would be his advice to the Tamil diaspora in engaging with the ‘International Community’. TamilNet posed the question to Professor Boyle following his recent interview on Bosnian ‘peace’ negotiations to the Institute for Research of Genocide, Canada.

[Full text of Prof Boyle's interview to the Institute for Research of Genocide is here.]
Prof. Francis Boyle
Prof. Francis A. Boyle, University of Illinois College of Law
When asked whether ethnicity or nationalism, or socio-economic problems was the main issue of the conflict, Boyle said, "it was outright genocide by Yugoslavia and Milosevic against the Bosnians. They proclaimed independence as was requested by the European Union. The EU put out guidelines and said to Bosnia and Croatia that they needed to have elections. They had elections and they voted for independence and they were hit with genocide and aggression," Boyle told the Canadian organization on Genocide research.

On the behavior of the British representative at the peace negotiations for Bosnia, Boyle said, "I dealt personally with David Owen. He is a typical British, imperialist, establishment, racist individual who believed Muslims were an inferior race of people. We were just supposed to do what he told us to do. I made it clear that that was not going to happen on my watch."

"Europe just did not want a Muslim state in Europe. It was that simple. It went back to the crusades.

[…]

This has to do with anti-Muslim prejudice in Europe going back to the crusades, at least. At that time, before 9/11 2001, we really didn’t have that in the United States. We didn’t have experience with the crusades and all the rest of that. But eventually, Clinton would go along with a carve-up too," Boyle said.

On the conduct of US representative in the talks, Boyle said, "Cyrus Vance was running the show. That was clear. He was the de facto representative of the US Government. Everyone knew that. Even though he technically represented the United Nations, everyone knew that Vance was there speaking pretty much on behalf of the US Government. He had been former Secretary of State. That’s the way people looked at Vance, that he had the backing of the US Government behind him. Of course Vance never said that, to the best of my knowledge, but that is the way people looked at Vance."

External Links:
IRG: Interview with Francis Boyle

ஞாயிறு, 28 ஜூலை, 2013

Administer justice to GoSL genocidaires on basis of Truth, says Boyle

Administer justice to GoSL genocidaires on basis of Truth, says Boyle

[TamilNet, Saturday, 27 July 2013, 18:51 GMT]
Commenting on Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh's statement that India has “long advocated the creation of an environment in Sri Lanka in which all communities, particularly the Sri Lankan Tamils, are masters of their own destiny within the framework of a united Sri Lanka,” Professor Boyle, an expert in International law, said that this was not an appropriate remedy to deal with genocidaires, adding, "It would be like asking the Jews to engage in a Truth and Reconciliation Process with the Nazis. The very idea is absurd and insulting upon its face alone." India's Prime Minister was responding to Chief Minister Jayalalithaa statement urging the Center to ensure that the process of democratic decentralization, integral to the survival of the Tamils in Sri Lanka, should lead to the Tamils realising their legitimate aspirations.


Professor Boyle said, "Most experts in the fields of international human rights law and international criminal law believe that a Truth and Reconciliation Process is not the appropriate remedy to deal with genocidaires and their victims.

"It would be like asking the Jews to engage in a Truth and Reconciliation Process with the Nazis. The very idea is absurd and insulting upon its face alone," Boyle said.

Prof Boyle added, "Rather, the international community set up the Nuremberg Charter, Judgment and Principles as well as the Genocide Convention to deal with the Nazi extermination of the Jews.

"That is why I have proposed that the United Nations General Assembly establish The International Criminal Tribunal for Sri Lanka as a “subsidiary organ” under U.N. Charter Article 22 that would be modeled upon the Statute for the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda.

"Justice must be administered to the GOSL genocidaires on the basis of Truth. Therefore, we must have a Truth and Justice Process with respect to the GOSL genocidaires," Boyle said.


புதன், 24 ஜூலை, 2013

UN Sri Lanka tribunal will avoid ICC jurisdictional

UN Sri Lanka tribunal will avoid ICC jurisdictional issues, says Boyle

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=IWfHr3GsddE
 [TamilNet, Tuesday, 23 July 2013, 00:43 GMT]
The United Nations General Assembly (GA) must immediately establish an International Criminal Tribunal for Sri Lanka (ICTSL) as a "subsidiary organ" under U.N. Charter Article 22, and organized along the lines of the International Criminal Tribunal for Yugoslavia (ICTY), which was established by the Security Council, said Professor Francis Boyle, an expert in International Law, while commenting on the appointment of Samantha Power as the U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations, and advocating that Ms Power should follow the leadership of Madeline Albright who spearheaded the setting up of the ICTY. This will avoid the jurisdictional hurdles in the ICC taking up criminal matters related to a non-signatory state, Boyle added.

Albright on the establishment of ICTY
The purpose of the ICTSL would be to investigate and prosecute Sri Lanka war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide against the Peoples of Lebanon and Palestine--just as the ICTY did for the victims of international crimes committed by Serbia and the Milosevic Regime throughout the Balkans, Professor Boyle said.

According to Boyle, the establishment of ICTSL would provide some small degree of justice to the victims of Sri Lanka's war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide against the Tamil people in NorthEast--just as the ICTY has done in the Balkans. Furthermore, the establishment of ICTSL by the U.N. General Assembly would serve as a deterrent effect upon Sri Lanka's polical leaders such as Sri Lanka's President Mahinda Rajapakse, his sibling and Defense Secretary, Gothabaya Rajapakse, another brother and minister for Development, Basil Rajapakse, Military Commander Sarath Fonseka and other top generals that they will be prosecuted for their further infliction of international crimes upon the Tamils from the NorthEast of Sri Lanka, Professor Boyle said.

Behind the scenes of ICTY
Tamil political activists agreed that without such a deterrent, Sri Lanka will likely continue the cultural genocide including forced colonization, grabing land from Tamil civilians, and militarization of day-to-day life and engaging the military in civilian affairs.

"For the U.N. General Assembly to establish ICTSL could stop the further development of this momentum towards a regional if not global catastrophe," Boyle added.

"People need to understand that Power could push for an International Criminal Tribunal for Sri Lanka on the basis of UN Charter article 22 to be set up by the UN General Assembly, thus avoiding the jurisdictional problems with the International Criminal Court since Sri Lanka is not a party and it appears that China would veto any referral by the Security Council to the ICC," Boyle further said.

"The UN General Assembly could take the Statute for the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda and transform it into the Statute for the International Criminal Tribunal for Sri Lanka," Professor Boyle said.

Francis A. Boyle is a graduate of the University of Chicago and Harvard Law School. He has advised numerous international bodies in the areas of human rights, war crimes, genocide, nuclear policy, and bio warfare. He received a PHD in political science from Harvard University.

External Links:
UN:International Criminal Tribunal Rwanda: ICTR
ICTY:International Criminal Tribunal for Yugoslavia
ICTY:Karadzic, Mladic indictment
UN:Charter of the United Nations
Gen:Cambodia Tribunal

சனி, 20 ஜூலை, 2013

Can Power, silent on Sri Lanka genocide, redeem herself in UN, asks Boyle

Can Power, silent on Sri Lanka genocide, redeem herself in UN, asks Boyle

[TamilNet, Saturday, 20 July 2013, 00:50 GMT]
The Director of Multilateral Affairs and Human Rights of the U.S. National Security Council, Samantha Power, who has been nominated for U.S. ambassador to the United Nations, has been attending a Senate hearing on the nomination this week where she has been forcefully advocating action to stop “the grotesque atrocities being carried out by the Assad regime,” Washington media reported. Professor Boyle, pointing out Power's conspicuous silence during the killing of Tamil civilians reaching genocidal proportions by the Sri Lanka military, said that Power now has a chance to "redeem" herself by establishing an International Criminal Tribunal for Sri Lanka, as did her predecessor Madeline Albright to the former Yugoslavia.
Samantha Power
Samantha Power
Professor Boyle said, "[Samantha] Power stood by and watched 150,000 Tamils be exterminated by the GOSL and did nothing to stop it that I am aware of.

"Despite the fact that Article I of the Genocide Convention clearly required that the United States government and all of its officials “undertake to prevent and to punish” genocide, Power did not “prevent” the GOSL genocide against the Tamils," Boyle said, adding, "But now she has the opportunity to redeem herself, the Obama administration and the United States government by acting “to punish” the GOSL genocide against the Tamils.

"Her predecessor Madeleine Albright as US Ambassador to the United Nations almost single-handedly established the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia for the punishment of all the Serbian genocidaires against the Bosnians, including Milosevic, Karadzic, and Mladic, inter alia. Power has the right, the power and the obligation to do the same against the GOSL genocidaires, especially the Rajapaksas.

"We must all demand and settle for nothing less from her than what Madeleine Albright did for the Bosnians: Bring all the GOSL genocidaires to Justice," Professor Boyle said.

Ms. Power won a Pulitzer for "A Problem from Hell: America and the Age of Genocide," her book about America's response to genocide. In the book she argues that American foreign policy in this area has failed; we promised "never again" after the Holocaust but willfully ignored genocides in Cambodia, Iraq, Bosnia, and Rwanda, she had earlier said, before she was invited to join the Obama's first campaign.

Professor Francis A. Boyle is the author of "The Tamil Genocide by Sri Lanka (Clarity Press: 2010)," and "The Bosnian People Charge Genocide! (Aletheia Press: 1996)."

Related Articles:
06.06.13   Spectators to Sri Lanka genocide ascend in Obama's inner cir..
22.02.13   Blake, architect of Tamil tragedy, spectator to genocide
29.04.12   Samantha Power to chair US genocide prevention effort
14.07.10   No peace without justice, says Obama's envoy to Srebrenica
15.06.10   Obama's Genocide Expert meets Mahinda Rajapaksa
15.04.09   Sri Lanka, 'Obama's first problem from hell,' ICP says


External Links:
Wsj: Questions for Samantha Power
WP: Samantha Power’s toleration of atrocities
Clarity: Tamil Genocide by Sri Lanka
WP: Samantha Power, at confirmation hearing, faults U.N. for ‘disgrace’ in Syria

சனி, 13 ஏப்ரல், 2013

Joke and a fraud, Boyle slams Kerry's New Year message

Joke and a fraud, Boyle slams Kerry's New Year message

[TamilNet, Friday, 12 April 2013, 11:46 GMT]
Noting the new U.S. Secretary of State, John Kerry's New Year Statement that included, "[t]he New Year brings with it a new opportunity for all Sri Lankans to join together in the spirit of peace and reconciliation," Professor Boyle, an expert in international law and a keen watcher of the treacherous conduct of the international community in watching the genocide of Tamils unfold in Sri Lanka, said, "Kerry [is] lumping the Tamils in with the genocidal Sinhala. It would be like Kerry congratulating the German Jews together with the German Nazis on the German New Year."

Full statement of Prof. Boyle sent to TamilNet follows:
    Boy, this is a real Joke and a Fraud. Kerry lumping the Tamils in with the genocidal Sinhala. It would be like Kerry congratulating the German Jews together with the German Nazis on the German New Year.

    Then Kerry asking the German Jews “to join together in the spirit of peace and reconciliation” with the German Nazis. And then Kerry in the name of President Obama asking the German Jews to “work” with the German Nazis in order “to make progress on reconciliation and accountability four years after the end of the” Holocaust “which divided your country.”

    According to Kerry there should be “new beginnings and fresh promise” between the German Jews and the German Nazis.

    Kerry has a law degree from Boston College Law School. Obviously, they never taught the Nuremberg Charter, the Nuremberg Judgment and the Nuremberg Principles there.
The following is the full New Year message released in a press statement from Secretary Kerry's office:
Senator John Kerry
Senator John Kerry
    I congratulate Sri Lankans around the world as you celebrate Sinhala and Tamil New Year, and offer my warmest wishes for happy holiday and prosperous New Year.

    Every year this celebration brings the hope of new beginnings and fresh promise. The New Year brings with it a new opportunity for all Sri Lankans to join together in the spirit of peace and reconciliation.

    On behalf of President Obama and the American people, I am eager to support the Sri Lankan people in this journey as you work to make progress on reconciliation and accountability four years after the end of the conflict which divided your country.

    The United States stands ready to partner with Sri Lanka and all Sri Lankans as you deal with these important issues.
Earlier, Prof Boyle concluded that there was a clear link between the 2009 Kerry Report and Kerry’s State Department, and said, "The callous and callow Kerry Report came right after the GOSL genocidal massacre of about 100,000 Tamils in Vanni, recommending that the United States government abandon all principles and instead aid and abet the continued GOSL repression and persecution of the Tamils. That is precisely the policy we now see in operation with Kerry as U.S. Secretary of State. This latest UNHRC Resolution sponsored by Kerry’s State Department and acting pursuant to his instructions proves it. Kerry should be fired," said Boyle.

Related Articles:
24.03.13   New US Secretary of State responsible for Geneva injustice: ..
22.12.09   Boston Tamils protest over Kerry report

திங்கள், 25 மார்ச், 2013

New US Secretary of State responsible for Geneva injustice: Boyle

New US Secretary of State responsible for Geneva injustice: Boyle

[TamilNet, Sunday, 24 March 2013, 15:15 GMT]
The New US Secretary of State John Kerry, who assumed office on 1 Feb 2013, was the Chairman of the Committee on Foreign Relations in 2009 that brought out a report advising the USA to help Sri Lanka’s military without insisting on political solutions. Finding a clear link between the 2009 Kerry Report and Kerry’s State Department, US Professor of Law, Francis A Boyle said, "The callous and callow Kerry Report came right after the GOSL genocidal massacre of about 100,000 Tamils in Vanni, recommending that the United States government abandon all principles and instead aid and abet the continued GOSL repression and persecution of the Tamils. That is precisely the policy we now see in operation with Kerry as U.S. Secretary of State. This latest UNHRC Resolution sponsored by Kerry’s State Department and acting pursuant to his instructions proves it. Kerry should be fired," said Boyle.
PDF IconUS-Kerry press release on Geneva
resolution on Sri Lanka
The U.S. Secretary of State, John Kerry's recent press statement which characterized the UNHRC Sri Lanka resolution as encouraging "the Government of Sri Lanka to continue on the path toward lasting peace and prosperity following decades of civil war and instability," and which expressed U.S.'s readiness "to continue engagement" with Colombo, and sidestepped accountability for the war-crimes committed by Sri Lanka, has alarmed Tamil activists, and raised the specter of a resumption of a passive US policy based on the 2009-Kerry report. This report was assailed by rights groups as "incredibly shoddy, ill-informed piece of work that grossly overstates the strategic importance of Sri Lanka to the U.S. and woefully understates the degree of abuses carried out by Colombo."
The December 2009 Report, "Sri Lanka: Recharting U.S. Strategy after the War," released by the Committee on Foreign Relations of which John Kerry was the chairman, recommended, inter alia:
John Kerry, US Secretary of State
John Kerry, US Secretary of State
US should focus on economy and security of the island instead of humanitarian considerations, IDPs and civil society; should also invest in Sinhalese parts of the country instead of just focusing on North and East; should resume training of Sri Lankan military officials to ensure human rights in future operations as well as to build critical relationships and implied that US should not emphasize on political reform as a condition to assistance, bringing rift in US- Sri Lanka relations making the latter to align with countries of alternative model of development.

Diaspora circles commented after the release of the Kerry report that while pre-2006 US policy gave verbal precedence to political solution over military solution, and later provided support to a military solution, has now isolated the Tamil national struggle as a non-entity in U.S.'s geopolitical considerations.

Rights group slammed the contents of 2009 Kerry report. "Maybe the people who wrote the report don’t know anything about Sri Lanka or maybe they’re of the school that says that everything on the planet is strategic," said Brad Adams, Asia director for Human Rights Watch. "The huge human-rights and humanitarian problems that continue there are not small; they’re central to any principled diplomatic engagement with Sri Lanka at this point. So [the notion] that we are in a competition with China, which I think is driving this, is misplaced," Adams further said.

In this context, the Secretary of State Kerry's statement on the UNHCR resolution has dismayed Tamil diaspora circles over the possible ominous policy evolution in a downward direction as regards Tamils' future welfare, and on the possible adverse impact to the Tamil struggle seeking justice, accountability, and assertion of political and fundamental rights.

Chronology:

வியாழன், 21 மார்ச், 2013

Adopting draft resolution will violate Genocide Convention, says Boyle

Adopting draft resolution will violate Genocide Convention, says Boyle

[TamilNet, Thursday, 21 March 2013, 00:01 GMT]
Commenting on the draft resolution being circulated by the United States at the the Geneva sessions of the UNHRC, Francis Boyle, Professor at the School of Law, University of Illinois and an expert in international law said that UNHRC and its member states, by adopting the draft resolution (3rd draft) will be abetting the on-going systematic structural genocide in vilolation of the 1948 Genocide Convention. The vote on Sri Lanka resolution is likely to take place as early as Thursday in Geneva, according to sources in Geneva.

Prof Francis Boyle, University of Illinois College of Law
Prof Francis Boyle, University of Illinois College of Law
Full text of Prof. Boyle's comment follows:

    "By means of adopting this draft Resolution, the U.N. Human Rights Council and its Member States will thereby further whitewash and “bluewash” and facilitate and aid and abet the ongoing campaign of genocide by the GoSL against the Tamils in violation of the 1948 Genocide Convention and in particular but not limited to their article 1 obligation “to prevent and to punish” genocide as well as their article 3(e) obligation that prohibits and criminalizes “complicity in genocide.”


The US-sponsored draft resolution "calls" the Sri Lankan government to conduct an "independent and credible" investigation into allegations of human rights violations. The draft resolution has not ceded to demands of human rights bodies for an independent international investigation, as being called by the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Navaneetham Pillay.

* * *


Also last year, in March 2012, Professor Boyle had warned the Tamil diaspora and supporters like him against falling into the trap being created by the US Government.

"I served as Legal Adviser to the Palestinian Delegation to the Middle East Peace Negotiations starting in the Fall of 1991. Since that time, Israel’s strategy has always been to STALL AND DELAY while they destroy the Palestinians.

"The entire world is going along with that strategy. GoSL is doing the same thing to the Tamils here. And the entire world is going along with it. We are being treated like the Palestinians. We need to come up with an entirely new strategy.

"If we proceed down this path there will never be GoSL accountability for anything. GoSL will drag it all out until the Tamils are dead. Stall for time until the clock runs out like at a basketball game or a football game when the your side is ahead. GoSL is trying to run out the clock on us," Boyle had said in a note sent to TamilNet.

* * *


Amidst lack of strategy by the Tamil diaspora activists, the students of Jaffna University, by their peaceful protests which were brutally attacked by the SL military in November 2012, effectively exposed how the ‘LLRC’ was being implemented by the Sri Lankan State on the ground.

Now, the students in Tamil Nadu have come forward with a strategy to arrest the situation. Their strategy is peoples struggle to checkmate the realities in the region. By continuing to hold mass demonstrations and hunger strikes, protesting the resolution, they have exposed the ultimate culprits to not only the Tamil public across the world, but also to the Establishment-centric Tamil politicians in the island and political acitivists in the diaspora.

Chronology:

வியாழன், 27 டிசம்பர், 2012

Systemic disappearances qualify as crimes against humanity in ICC, says Boyle

Systemic disappearances qualify as crimes against humanity in ICC, says Boyle

[TamilNet, Wednesday, 26 December 2012, 22:46 GMT]
The enforced disappearances of human beings that are widespread and systematic, such as the abductions of Tamils in the NorthEast including the midnight abduction of 28-year-old Mrs Soundararajan Sivamalar in Uduvil, Jaffna, on Christmas eve by Sri Lanka's Terrorism Division, are a Crime against Humanity under the Rome Statute for the International Criminal Court (ICC), Professor Boyle of the University of Illinois College of Law said. "So if Gotobhaya travels to an ICC Member State, it might be possible to get him prosecuted in the visiting country under its domestic implementing legislation for the Rome Statute," Boyle said.

Spokesperson for Tamils Against Genocide (TAG), a US-based activist group said, "While we are fighting to overturn the protection given to the primary genocidaire, Mahinda Rajapakse, by the United States Department of State under the extra-legal and discretionary application of the doctrine of Head of State Immunity, we will not have a similar issue with sibling Gotabhaya Rajakapakse, when he travels to a ICC signatory state," TAG said.

Boyle added, "under the ICC Rome Statute, it is a requirement that member states enact domestic implementing legislation making ICC Rome Statute Crimes domestic crimes as well. Hence it might be possible to prosecute Gotobaya under these domestic ICC Crimes even if the ICC does not have jurisdiction.

"This is how the objectors scared President Bush out of traveling to Switzerland by demanding his prosecution if he showed up there under their domestic implementing legislation for the ICC even though the USA is not a party to the Rome Statute," Boyle added.

Most of Europe now has domestic implementing legislation for the ICC. International Criminal Court Act No. 41, 2002 facilitates compliance by Australia with obligations under the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, and for related purposes.

Chronology:


Related Articles:
25.12.12   Sri Lanka’s terror abductions, arrests, summons mark Christm..
17.12.12   40 ex-LTTE members abducted within one week, IOM, UN blamed ..
21.06.10   Intoxicating hubris

ஞாயிறு, 8 ஏப்ரல், 2012

Boyle compares Syria action, dismisses UNHRC resolution as a "fraud"

Boyle compares Syria action, dismisses UNHRC resolution as a "fraud"

[TamilNet, Friday, 06 April 2012, 23:53 GMT]
Dismissing the US sponsored United Nations Human Rights Council Resolution as "a fraud," Professor Francis Boyle, an expert in international law, said, "if the US were serious about Government of Sri Lanka (GoSL) genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes against the Tamils, US would have done something like it did to Syria this week." The U.S. State Department established a Clearinghouse on Syria and provided $1.25m to assist to "collect, collate, analyze, and securely store evidence, documentation, and other information concerning human rights abuses and violations, while protecting witnesses and sources."

While the conduct of the Syrian Government is similar to that of the Rajapakse Government in its crimes committed against the Tamils, the number of people affected in Syria is an order of magnitude less than that in Sri Lanka.

Boyle pointed out that until U.S. takes action similar to that it has taken against Syria in helping the Tamils to "collect, collate, analyze, and securely store evidence" that will enable the victims to "develop case dossiers that could support prosecutions in Syrian, hybrid, or international courts," diaspora should not be optimistic about U.S.'s intentions.

Full text of the announcement on Syria by the State Department follows:
    Recognizing that perpetrators of gross violations of human rights in Syria must be held to account, and that the Syrian people will lead the way, the United States will work with international partners to establish a Syria Accountability Clearinghouse that will support Syrian and international efforts to promote accountability. By providing a forum for coordination, the Clearinghouse will advance efforts to assist and train the Syrian people and partner organizations to collect, collate, analyze, and securely store evidence, documentation, and other information concerning human rights abuses and violations, while protecting witnesses and sources. The record that is compiled could be used for a broad range of transitional justice and reconciliation processes, including truth-seeking, memorialisation, and prosecutions. These efforts will also help develop trial-ready dossiers against individuals responsible for violations of international or domestic criminal law. The Clearinghouse will be guided by a Steering Committee of representatives of the Syrian people, cooperating states, and regional organizations. Projects that could be coordinated via the Syria Accountability Clearinghouse would aim to: Train and mentor Syrian investigators/lawyers, human rights actors, and other NGOs/independent actors to collect information about the full range of human rights abuses and violations.
  • Establish a secure storage facility, including a database, for collected information.
  • Establish protection and security best practices and procedures and seek assistance from states to implement them.
  • Establish a “Prosecutors’ Unit” to collect and analyze available evidence and develop case dossiers that could support prosecutions in Syrian, hybrid, or international courts.
There may also be ways for the Clearinghouse to complement the efforts of the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, which is facilitating safe and secure storage of information and evidence collected by the Commission of Inquiry.

The Syria Accountability Clearinghouse will maintain secure virtual linkages with affiliated groups and organizations around the world, including in Syria. The United States will provide an initial $1.25 million to support the Clearinghouse and related accountability efforts, and ask other partner nations and organizations to provide additional funding and support for these accountability efforts. While the US sponsored resolution's thrust was in the implementation of the recommendations of the LLRC, the recent "factual supplement" on Sri Lanka's war released by the US Office of Global Criminal Justice headed by Ambassador Stephen Rapp, pointed out the serious defects of the LLRC in addressing the International Humanitarian, and Human Rights Law violations.

வியாழன், 15 மார்ச், 2012

Boyle warns Tamil diaspora against "Stall and Delay" diplomacy at UNHRC

Boyle warns Tamil diaspora against "Stall and Delay" diplomacy at UNHRC

[TamilNet, Tuesday, 13 March 2012, 23:55 GMT]
Noting the U.S. ambassador to UNHRC Eileen Donahoe's statement that the resolution forwarded by the U.S. has been toned down from an earlier version that sought a government action plan on accountability and reconciliation by June, to now calling for the U.N. Human Rights Commissioner to report to the council a year from now on the steps Sri Lanka has taken," Professor Boyle, an expert in international law and a keen observer of Sri Lanka politics, said the U.S. Government is going along with the Government of Sri Lanka (GoSL) strategy to run the clock out on the Tamils, just as the Israelis are doing to the Palestinians with USA support. The Tamil diaspora and supporters like us should not fall into this trap, but instead come up with a entirely new strategy."

Professor Francis A. Boyle, University of Illinois College of Law
Professor Francis A. Boyle, University of Illinois
"I served as Legal Adviser to the Palestinian Delegation to the Middle East Peace Negotiations starting in the Fall of 1991. Since that time, Israel’s strategy has always been to STALL AND DELAY while they destroy the Palestinians.

"The entire world is going along with that strategy. GoSL is doing the same thing to the Tamils here. And the entire world is going along with it. We are being treated like the Palestinians. We need to come up with an entirely new strategy.

"If we proceed down this path there will never be GoSL accountability for anything. GoSL will drag it all out until the Tamils are dead. Stall for time until the clock runs out like at a basketball game or a football game when the your side is ahead. GoSL is trying to run out the clock on us," Boyle said in a note sent to TamilNet.

Chronology:


Related Articles:
08.02.12   Boyle: Appointing alleged war-criminals to UN posts, a viola..
30.01.12   Boyle: US should publicly accuse Colombo of committing war c..
18.12.11   Boyle: Tamils safety possible only under separate state
30.04.11   Boyle: Word "Genocide" missing in UN Panel's war crimes repo..
26.04.11   Ban Ki Moon, Accessory After the Fact to Sri Lanka war crime..
16.04.11   Boyle reacts to UN report: "Creating Tamil Eelam, the only r..

வியாழன், 9 பிப்ரவரி, 2012

Boyle: Appointing alleged war-criminals to UN posts, a violation of UN Charter

Boyle: Appointing alleged war-criminals to UN posts, a violation of UN Charter

[TamilNet, Wednesday, 08 February 2012, 05:30 GMT]
While Ban Ki Moon's spokesman Martin Nesirky insisted that Ban is powerless to stop the proposed appointment of alleged war-criminal Shavendra Silva to an UN adviser position, Professor Boyle, an expert in international law, said, "U.N. Secretary-General has a Charter obligation to determine that the terms of article 101(3) have been satisfied before he appoints someone to the Staff irrespective of any alleged recommendation by the General Assembly," and therefore, "Ban to appoint a presumptive war criminal to his Staff would be ultra vires his powers under the terms of article 101(3) and thus a violation of the Charter itself."

Professor Francis A. Boyle, University of Illinois College of Law
Professor Francis A. Boyle, University of Illinois
Text of the legal note Professor Boyle sent to TamilNet follows:
    The United Nations Charter establishes Six Independent Organs: The Security Council, the General Assembly, the Economic and Social Council, the Trusteeship Council , the Secretariat, and the International Court of Justice. The U.N. Charter was deliberately drafted so that no one Organ had the right to order around any other Organ. Chapter XV of the Charter sets forth the independent powers and responsibilities of The Secretariat. According to article 97 thereof, the Secretary-General is the chief administrative officer of the United Nations Organization. Article 101 of the Charter provides: "The staff shall be appointed by the Secretary-General under regulations established by the General Assembly." However, these General Assembly regulations cannot trump the terms of the Charter itself. In this regard, article 101(3) clearly states: "The paramount consideration in the employment of the staff and in the determination of the conditions of service shall be the necessity of securing the highest standards of efficiency, competence, and integrity." The U.N. Secretary-General has a Charter obligation to determine that the terms of article 101(3) have been satisfied before he appoints someone to the Staff irrespective of any alleged recommendation by the General Assembly. Certainly the U.N. Secretary-General has a Charter obligation to reject a presumptive war criminal for appointment to the Staff on the grounds of his prima facie absence of "integrity." Indeed, for the U.N. Secretary General to appoint a presumptive war criminal to his Staff would be ultra vires his powers under the terms of article 101(3) and thus a violation of the Charter itself. For these reasons, the U.N. Secretary General must reject both Silva and Kohona for any U.N. Staff Appointment.
Inner City Press reported that even many member states describe the appointments as a travesty or a "new low," and say they are pushing Sri Lanka to pull Silva back, even if only to replace him with Permanent Representative Palitha Kohona, who also played a role in the White Flag killing of prospective surrenderees, along with Ban's chief of staff Vijay Nambiar.

Professor Francis A. Boyle taught United Nations Law in the College of Harvard University during the 1976-1977 Academic Year, and later for several years at the University of Illinois College of Law in Champaign. See his Foundations of World Order(Duke University Press: 1999).

Chronology:


Related Articles:
28.01.12   Silva's proposed UN appointment elicits condemnation from Ri..


External Links:
ICP: At UN Screening on Sri Lanka Murders, Kohona Tells Press to Ask Nambiar, Silva Says It Was 53rd Div - Lies Agreed On
FR: Foundations of World Order: The Legalist Approach to International Relations, 1898-1922
ICP: Amid Move to Switch From Criminal Silva, Ban Dismisses Predecessor Criticism
ICP: Sri Lanka Got Saudi & Nepal to Stand Down, Silva to Now Cede to Kohona?

செவ்வாய், 31 ஜனவரி, 2012

Boyle: US should publicly accuse Colombo of committing war crimes

Boyle: US should publicly accuse Colombo of committing war crimes

[TamilNet, Monday, 30 January 2012, 00:40 GMT]
Pointing to the recent investigative reports in media outlets noting US may possess crucial supporting material to incriminating evidence from senior military commanders of Colombo committing war-crimes, to exposures on Wikileaks of Colombo-based US Ambassadors' reported knowledge of high level Sri Lanka officials' complicity to war crimes, and to incriminating reports from the UN and NGOs on alleged war-crimes, Professor Boyle of University of Illinois, College of Law, said, in similar circumstances Secretary of State Eagleburger accused Radovan Karadzic of committing war-crimes during the Bosnian genocide, and the Obama administration can, and should, do the same thing to political and military leaders in Colombo.

Acting U.S. Secretary of State Larry Eagleburger publicly condemns Radovan Karadzic
Acting U.S. Secretary of State Larry Eagleburger publicly condemns Karadzic
In a note sent to TamilNet, Professor Boyle said, "Under similar circumstances during the Bosnian genocide, U.S. Secretary of State Lawrence Eagleburger under President Bush Sr. publicly accused Bosnian Serb President Radovan Karadzic of committing war crimes and crimes against humanity, on the basis of evidence compiled by the US Government, though he did not go so far as to accuse Karadzic of genocide because of the political implications.

"But it seems to me that Secretary of State Clinton or at least Assistant Secretary of State for Human Rights Mike Posner can and should do the same here. If the Bush Sr. administration did the right thing for the Bosnians, then certainly and a fortiori the Obama administration can and should do the right thing for the Tamils."

In addition to the evidence that has been emerging recently, Prof. Boyle said earlier, "United States Defense Department will have all the evidence necessary to indict Sri Lanka officials who were responsible for the 2009 May massacre. Expatriate Tamils have to keep working until they find a way to have this information accessible to UN prosecutors."

Related Articles:
29.01.12   STF killed Trinco students, Basil Rajapakse told Blake
29.01.12   US's dissonant positions boon to Sri Lanka's war-criminals
02.01.12   Extra-judicial execution of Trincomalee students, Sixth anni..
13.11.10   Demand US to provide war crimes evidence to UN Panel, urges ..
13.03.10   Demand US to reveal more inculpatory war crimes evidence, ur..
13.03.10   US rights report adds to Colombo's woes over war-crime accus..


External Links:
Truthout: Sri Lankan General Admits War Crimes; US May Hold Crucial Supporting Evidence

திங்கள், 9 ஜனவரி, 2012

No amnesty for war-criminals

No amnesty for war-criminals, says UN's 

Navi Pillay

[TamilNet, Sunday, 08 January 2012, 04:01 GMT]
Granting amnesty to perpetrators of war crimes and human rights abuses under Yemen's presidential power transition deal would be against international law, the United Nations human rights chief said on Friday, undermining the peace agreement, Reuters reported. The implications of this to pending litigation of sitting and ex-Presidents in courts around the world are significant according to legal sources in Washington. Professor Francis Boyle commented that while the UN pronouncements were directed towards Yemen, for bringing the culpable Sri Lanka leaders to justice for crimes committed during the Mu'l'livaaykkaal massacre, continued action outside Sri Lanka by Tamil expatriates was crucial.

Professor Boyle in a note sent to TamilNet said: "The GOSL [Government of Sri Lanka] are so brazen in their genocidal criminality that they are not even going to bother giving themselves “amnesty.” They will continue to tough it out and figure they can get away with it forever. So far every government in the world including and especially India has let them do so, as well as the United Nations Organization. It is up to us People to turn the situation around and hold the GOSL accountable. 50,000 massacred Tamils in Vanni demand no less of our Common Humanity!"

Noting that Pillay has previously blamed Yemeni government forces for using live ammunition against unarmed protesters and has said President Ali Abdullah Saleh should not get amnesty in a deal to persuade him to leave power, Reuters summarized Navi Pillay's statement as follows:

    "I have been closely following the events in Yemen, particularly the very contentious debate about an amnesty law to be presented to Parliament shortly," "International law and the U.N. policy are clear on the matter: amnesties are not permissible if they prevent the prosecution of individuals who may be criminally responsible for international crimes including war crimes, crimes against humanity, genocide, and gross violations of human rights." "Based on information we have gathered, there is reason to believe that some of these crimes were committed in Yemen during the period for which an amnesty is under consideration. Such an amnesty would be in violation of Yemen's international human rights obligations,"
Saudi Arabia has supported Saleh by donating diesel and crude oil and the United States, which long backed Saleh as a pillar of its "counter-terrorism" strategy, helped craft the power transition deal giving him immunity from prosecution, Reuters report said.

External Links:
Reuters: UN's Pillay: Yemen peace-deal amnesty may be unlawful