Navi pillay லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி
Navi pillay லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி

புதன், 2 அக்டோபர், 2013

Question raised on truth of Navi Pillay statement

Question raised on truth of Navi Pillay statement

[TamilNet, Wednesday, 02 October 2013, 00:59 GMT]
UN Human Rights chief Ms Navanetham Pillay, in a press interview in Colombo towards the end of her recent visit to the island, has said that no one she had met there used the word genocide. TamilNet comes to know that there were specific instances in which responsible civil society members meeting her had told her about genocide in the island, using the very word genocide in English. Ms Navi Pillay held her civil society meetings under ‘Chatham House’ rules. In Vanni she told people that they could whisper in her ear. Has she misused such conditions to suppress what had actually been told to her, in order to shield an imperial design that accommodates genocide by the Agent State? Why should she hide the fact that the island Tamils in deed spoke to her on genocide, asks the civil society in the island.

Ms. Navi Pillay gave an exclusive interview to Easwaran Rutnam, the editor of Colombo Gazzette, on 31 August.
“The Tamil Diaspora tends to often raise the issue that there is genocide taking place in Sri Lanka. During your visit have you seen something to that effect or is it an exaggeration,” asked Mr Rutnam.

Navi Pillay replied: “Well nobody used that word to me; not in authorities or civil society. Genocide is particularly a legal word. I [inaudible] people since I was judge on the genocide tribunal to say that there has to be proof of an intent to destroy in whole or in part a nation, a group. This is what happened in Rwanda. That is a clear case of genocide. However it’s not for me to judge. It’s only after proper investigations the judges, based on the evidence, can conclude whether and what crimes were committed.”

At least two respectable civil society members who met Navi Pillay have told her in clear terms that what had taken place was genocide and what is taking place after the war in 2009 is structural genocide committed on the nation of Eezham Tamils, TamilNet learns this week from first hand sources in the island.

If the former international judge, who has investigated Rwanda and has found it a clear case of genocide, now as the UN human rights chief chooses to suppress even submissions on genocide by Eezham Tamils in the island, then that itself is a matter for investigation, commented civil society circles in the island.

Washington and New Delhi that architected the war and the aftermath in the island do not concede that the Sinhala State has committed genocide and is committing structural genocide.

The upper layer of Tamils being pro-imperial is the obstacle to the Tamil struggle for liberation and self-determination, Tamil political analysts say.

If Ms Navi Pillay thinks that genocide in the island has to be proved through proper investigations why shouldn’t she call for it now itself, rather than waiting for the end results to ‘prove’ irrefutable, but then irredeemable genocide, ask civil society circles.

Ms Navi Pillay's predecessor Ms Louise Arbour went as the chief of the International Crisis Group (ICG), after her tenure in the UN. The ICG, under her leadership was in the forefront in denying the genocide committed on Eezham Tamils. At a later stage, when world public criticism was mounting on, the ICG came out with a similar statement like that of the present statement of Ms Navi Pillay that genocide has to be proved by legal means as though it is somebody else's job and not of their concern.


Chronology:


Related Articles:
09.10.12   Genocide needs investigation but separation contextually unw..


External Links:
Colombo Gazette: Pillay pessimistic after visit (Interview)

சனி, 28 செப்டம்பர், 2013

Navi Pillay's oral update, a gross betrayal of Tamils: Prof Ramasamy

Navi Pillay's oral update, a gross betrayal of Tamils: Prof Ramasamy

[TamilNet, Friday, 27 September 2013, 09:24 GMT]
The United Nations Human Rights High Commissioner Navanetham Pillay, in her latest oral update to the UN Human Rights Council is more concerned with whitewashing the Sri Lankan government than looking at the tragic situation of Tamils, writes Malaysia’s Penang State Deputy Chief Minister Professor P. Ramasamy, in an article sent to TamilNet on Thursday. “I think that the report should be more appropriately entitled ‘Strengthening Democracy in Sri Lanka’. In essence, close reading of the report in its entirety will reveal that she picked her words carefully to drive home the point that her main interest in Sri Lanka is not about inquiring into gross violation of human rights against Tamils, but to strengthen democracy and human rights in Sri Lanka. Tamils are not given prominence in the report. In fact, Tamils are treated just like another minority in the country, he further writes.

All the positive propaganda about Navi Pillay by certain governments and NGOs is a ploy to hide the real truth of the UN as an agency that serves the geo-political interests of the US and its allies,” Professor P Ramasamy writes.

Full text of the article by the Deputy Chief Minister of Pengang, Prof P. Ramasamy, follows:

Navi Pillay’s Oral Update: Gross Betrayals of Tamils!
Prof P Ramasamy
Prof P Ramasamy
Navi Pillay, the UN High Commissioner of Human Rights, a celebrated global personality and a champion of the underdogs, has proved it once again that she is after all an agent of the West. In her latest Oral Update, she is more concerned with whitewashing the Sri Lankan government than looking at the tragic situation of Tamils. This Oral Update is a follow up on what she presented in Colombo after having visited and examined the state of human rights in Sri Lanka.

This Oral Update is not different from the earlier one. It is obviously more polished and well-presented to the requirements of the prominent international players. I think that the report should be more appropriately entitled “Strengthening Democracy in Sri Lanka”. In essence, close reading of the report in its entirety will reveal that she picked her words carefully to drive home the point that her main interest in Sri Lanka is not about inquiring into gross violation of human rights against Tamils, but to strengthen democracy and human rights in Sri Lanka. Tamils are not given prominence in the report. In fact, Tamils are treated just like another minority in the country.

In this Update, she commends the excellent cooperation extended by the government. She gives credits to the impressive human rights achievement by the government with the help of the international community. She says that vast majority of the internally displaced persons had been settled another instance of achievement by the government. She is pleased that the government has taken the initiative to invite the Special Rapporteur from UN.

She thinks that the recent elections to the Northern Provincial Council will bring about better devolution of power. On the large military presence in Tamil areas, compulsory acquisition of private land and the role of military in civilian areas, she contends that all these are not simple and straightforward issues that could be resolved overnight. She thinks that these are complex issues that would have to be tackled through the initiatives of the various responsible ministries. Of all the internal mechanisms, she praises the LLRC. She is pleased that the government has accepted a number of its recommendations; for instance, the separation of the police from the Ministry of Defense. Touching on LTTE, she said that the outfit should be held responsible for war crimes.

Navi Pillay does not talk about the mass killings of Tamils during the last stages of the war. More than 100,000 Tamils were mercilessly killed by the Sri Lankan troops. Is she blind to this episode? While she talks about the intimidation of minorities, she avoids even mentioning the mass murder of Tamils. If she can gloss over such an incontrovertible fact, then she must definitely have a particular agenda in talking about human rights in Sri Lanka.

She mentions about the LTTE in relation to war crimes. What about the murderous Sinhala regime that decimated hundreds and thousands of Tamils with the support of the international community. Who raped hundreds of Tamil women? What about the thousands of Tamil prisoners languishing in prisons without any form of support? She praises the recent elections for the Northern Provincial Council, but what about the systematic attacks against candidate Ananthi?

This Update by Navi Pillay is highly irresponsible one. It is an insult to Tamils who suffered and endured thirty years of war. With two reports, she has marginalized the victims and exalted the oppressors. By her non-committal to the principles of democracy and human rights, she has weakened the demands for Tamils for justice and freedom. All the positive propaganda about Navi Pillay by certain governments and NGOs is a ploy to hide the real truth of the UN as an agency that serves the geo-political interests of the US and its allies.

In the final analysis, UN’s real intention is not so much to understand the sufferings of Tamils so that they could seek justice, but ensure that Sri Lankan government is “rehabilitated” so that it could shed its “international pariah” status. Naveen Pillay is doing a wonderful job in this direction!

Chronology:

புதன், 18 செப்டம்பர், 2013

Senior Jesuit priest in East harassed

Senior Jesuit priest in East harassed after meeting Navi Pillay

[TamilNet, Tuesday, 17 September 2013, 23:07 GMT]
60-year-old Jesuit Priest Fr Veeresan Yogeswaran, who is one of the leading human rights activists in the East, is at the receiving end of the SL government's ire after his meeting with UN Human Rights High Commissioner Navanetham Pillay during her recent visit to the island. Pamphlets decrying Fr Yogeswaran, printed in Sinhala and in erroneous Tamil – evidently not written by a Tamil – have been published in Trincomalee, some of which have been left outside his residence. Abusing Fr Yogeswaran S.J., as anti-Sri Lankan and someone who ‘betrayed his country’, the pamphlets also claim that he is living in a palatial house from where he was indulging in ‘conspiracy activities’ against the SL government.

Fr Yogeswaran harassed in Trincomalee


Navi Pillay who visited Trincomalee during her trip to the island last month had met Sri Lanka’s colonial military Governor of Eastern Province Rear Admiral (retd) Mohan Wijewickrama and the Sri Lankan Government Agents of the three districts in the East and the ruling UPFA’s Chief Minister of the province. She also met and interacted with the general public and human rights activists from Trincomalee.

Right before her visit to Trincomalee, SL military operatives visited several so-called welfare camps and took away people known for speaking out.

Fr Yogeswaran who runs the Centre for Promotion and Protection of Human Rights has been handling human rights issues on the legal front, in the Batticaloa district since 1985. He has handled cases of forced disappearances too in the district.

After his meeting with UN High Commissioner, the SL military intelligence has sought explanation from him over telephone.

Consequently, the pamphlets have been issued on the night of September 14.

In the meantime, the SL police personnel who visited his house on September 15, removed the pamphlets from the vicinity of his residence.

Deploying intelligence operatives on one hand and showcasing the so-called rule of law through the dramas of the SL police on the other, has become the order of the day in the occupied country of Eezham Tamils, civil activists in the East commented.
Fr Yogeswaran harassed in Trincomalee
Fr Yogeswaran harassed in Trincomalee

செவ்வாய், 10 செப்டம்பர், 2013

Navi Pillay, a big disappointment: Prof Ramasamy

Navi Pillay, a big disappointment: Prof Ramasamy

[TamilNet, Monday, 09 September 2013, 13:06 GMT]
Despite the publicity surrounding her visit, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Ms. Navanetham Pillay “was a big disappointment for Tamils in Sri Lanka and elsewhere. At the end of her visit, she basically revealed her true character of serving the interests of the UN and the larger interests of the Anglo-Saxon world,” writes Malaysia’s Penang State Deputy Chief Minister Professor P. Ramasamy, in an article sent to TamilNet on Monday. Accusing the UN for being an arm of the “arch imperialist power in the world, the United States of America,” Prof Ramasamy said that Ms Pillay’s visit had especially disappointed the sections of Tamils in the US and Europe that had thought that she would make a difference.

Full text of the article by Professor P. Ramasamy:
Prof P Ramasamy
Prof P Ramasamy
Navanetham Pillay, the chief of UN Human Rights, visited Sri Lanka and reported about the state of human rights in the country. Unlike her earlier hardline stand, her report was certainly mild in comparison. She lamented negatively about human rights in Sri Lanka and stated that regime was heading towards a more authoritarian path.

Beyond this, she was quite kind to the government, thanked the officials for their cooperation, providing accessibility to areas she visited and remarked that government's own mechanism, the LLRC, had made some positive moves in the direction of the promotion of human rights.

Ironically, contrary to expectations, her harshest criticism was not leveled at the cruel regime for the genocide of more than 100,000 innocent Tamils, but towards the LTTE. She vented a ferocious anger, uncharacteristic of a human rights person, against the LTTE and called it a "murderous" organization.

She urged the Tamil Diaspora not to glorify the outfit and in her opinion, the LTTE, was the prime cause of Tamil misery. Not knowing history or simply ignoring it for certain political expediency, she failed to realize that LTTE was not an autonomous growth, but a product of extreme Sinhala racism and hatred.

Pillay was fully aware of the propaganda unleashed by the Sri Lankan regime about her Tamil origin and the links they tried to establish between her and the LTTE.

Some Sinhala racist press went to the extent of labeling her as a "Tigress". Given this, Pillay from the outset was conscious of this label and wished to avoid it at all costs in order to establish her "objectivity".

From the beginning, she assiduously sought to underplay her Tamil origins by asserting a synthetic South African nationality. She was of Tamil origin, but Tamils never expected her to go all out to assist them. They knew here constraints, but merely wanted to be heard.

Despite the publicity surrounding her visit, Pillay was a big disappointment for Tamils in Sri Lanka and elsewhere. At the end of her visit, she basically revealed her true character of serving the interests of the UN and the larger interests of the Anglo-Saxon world.

Some sections of the Tamil community especially those in US and Europe heaped praises on her as highly educated and articulate person, a person who would make a difference to the affected people. Alas, following her report, this was not to be the case. By condemning the LTTE, something uncalled for, she also ended up by alienating those who had stood behind the liberation movement.

For 30 years, thousands of Tamil youth fought to achieve the liberation of Tamil Eelam. For 30 years, the LTTE gave hope, courage and dignity to Tamil people not only in Elam but elsewhere. LTTE might not be there anymore, but the fact remains that the vast majority of Tamils would not forget the herculean sacrifice of the liberation movement.

Who is Navi Pillay to suddenly emerge from nowhere to castigate or condemn the LTTE? She is just an exalted employee of UN that has ignored the plight of the poor nations. UN is a liberal arm of the arch imperialist power in the world, the United States of America. This outfit has been used by the US and its allies to wreck havoc on nations accused of human rights violation. The damage done by the US to countries is unimaginable!

It is my humble request to Pillay to keep her comments about the LTTE to her or to those "bleeding" heart liberals. She has no business to condemn or comment about an organization that she can never understand. Her credentials from Harvard are just good to advance her career and nothing further.

Related Articles:
05.09.13   Eezham Tamil man self-immolates in front of Geneva UN office
11.07.13   Malaysia should boycott CHOGM, IC should call for referendum..

ஞாயிறு, 1 செப்டம்பர், 2013

‘Military presence in North-East worrying’: Navi Pillay

‘Military presence in North-East worrying’: Navi Pillay

[TamilNet, Saturday, 31 August 2013, 21:09 GMT]
“I was concerned to hear about the degree to which the military appears to be putting down roots and becoming involved in what should be civilian activities, for instance education, agriculture and even tourism,” Ms Navi Pillay, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, said at a press conference in Colombo on Saturday. Speaking at the conclusion of her visit to the island, Ms Pillay said that that the military presence in the North-East seemed “much greater than is needed for strictly military or reconstruction purposes,” also referring to the vulnerability of women to sexual abuse. While sympathizing with the spirit of the address of Ms Pillay, who has been at the receiving end of vulgar verbal abuse from Sinhala nationalists, Tamil activists in the island expressed regret that she was still conferring legitimacy to the GoSL’s genocidal blueprint called LLRC.

“The LLRC report contains a broad range of excellent recommendations regarding concrete improvements on human rights, and I was interested to receive a briefing on the extent of the implementation of some of those recommendations from the Permanent Secretary to the President. My Office will closely examine that update and future developments in the implementation of the LLRC, and I will of course make reference to any genuine progress in my reports to the Human Rights Council,” Navi Pillay had said.

But she also recognized that the LLRC “side-stepped the much-needed full, transparent, impartial investigation into the conduct of a conflict that saw numerous war crimes and other violations committed by both sides.”

Navi Pillay’s visit to the island raised great expectations from the genocide-affected Eezham Tamil nation and for all those believing in fundamental human rights.

It also provoked profane reactions from Sinhala nationalists. Sinhala ministers have not only called her a ‘LTTE stooge’, but have also passed crass sexist remarks about her. One obvious motivation for such remarks is her Tamil origin, even though it is Indian.

At this juncture, Ms Pillay chose to condemn the LTTE as “a murderous organization that committed numerous crimes and destroyed many lives.” She further criticized the diaspora for “the glorification of such a ruthless organization.”

But what the IC, including Ms Pillay fail time and again to recognize is that had the International Community intervened positively, whether it be in 1987 or in 2002, recognizing the sovereign Eezham Tamil nationhood, the genocidal character of the unitary Sri Lankan state and the impossibility of a just solution for the Tamils within the same, there would have been no violence of any considerable magnitude in the island, a Tamil human rights activists in Jaffna told TamilNet.

Further comments from the human rights activists follow:

To whitewash its own crimes and to accelerate its process of colonizing the North-East, the Sinhala state brought out the LLRC.

To whitewash their complicity in the genocide of the Eezham Tamil nation, the ICE harped on “positive recommendations” in the LLRC.

It is disheartening to see the much respected Ms Pillay also refer to the LLRC for its “excellent recommendations regarding concrete improvements on human rights”.

The LLRC is part of the problem of unitary Sri Lanka, just like the 13th amendment. It cannot be part of the solution for the Tamils. It is unjust to expect the Eezham Tamils, who faced the murderous ruthlessness of the Sri Lankan state for over six decades, and who lost over 100000 of their kin in 2009 alone, to have any faith in the LLRC.

Tamils world over will be watching with bated breath for Navanetham Pillay’s report to the Human Rights Council in September.

Whether she will identify the crimes of the Sri Lankan state for what they are is something that will be seen then.

* * *

Opening remarks by UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay at a press conference during her mission to Sri Lanka:

Colombo, 31 August 2013

Good morning, and thank you for coming.

As is customary at the end of official missions such as this, I would like to make some observations concerning the human rights situation in the country.

During my seven-day visit, I have held discussions with President Mahinda Rajapaksa, and senior members of the Government. These included the Ministers of External Affairs, Justice, Economic Development, National Languages and Social Integration, Youth Affairs and the Minister of Plantations Industries who is also Special Envoy to the President on Human Rights, as well as the Secretary of Defence. I also met the Chief Justice, Attorney-General, Leader of the House of Parliament and the Permanent Secretary to the President, who is head of the taskforce appointed to monitor the implementation of the report of the Lessons Learned and Reconciliation Commission (LLRC).

I had discussions with politicians who are not part of the current Government, namely the Leader of the Opposition and the leader of the Tamil National Alliance; in addition I met with the National Human Rights Commission, and a total of eight different gatherings of human rights defenders and civil society organizations in Colombo, Jaffna and Trincomalee. I also received briefings from the Governors and other senior officials in the Northern and Eastern Provinces.

I thank the Government for its invitation and its excellent cooperation during the planning and conduct of this very complex mission. It stated that I could go anywhere, and see anything I wished to see. And, despite some disturbing incidents which I will go into later, that commitment was honoured throughout.

Even though this is the longest official visit I have ever made to a single country, I am acutely conscious that I was unable to see everyone who requested a meeting. Nor will I be able to do justice to all the human rights issues facing the Sri Lankan people and government. Since I will be providing an oral update to the Human Rights Council in Geneva in late September, and a full written report in March next year, I will today confine myself to a few key issues that crystallized during the course of the mission.

I will divide these human rights issues into two parts: those related to the vicious and debilitating 27-year conflict between the Government and the LTTE, and its aftermath; and those that relate to the whole country.

Some media, ministers, bloggers and various propagandists in Sri Lanka have, for several years now, on the basis of my Indian Tamil heritage, described me as a tool of the LTTE. They have claimed I was in their pay, the “Tamil Tigress in the UN.” This is not only wildly incorrect, it is deeply offensive. This type of abuse has reached an extraordinary crescendo during this past week, with at least three Government Ministers joining in.

Firstly, let me say, I am a South African and proud of it.

Secondly, the LTTE was a murderous organization that committed numerous crimes and destroyed many lives. In fact, my only previous visit to Sri Lanka was to attend a commemoration of the celebrated legislator, peacemaker and scholar, Neelan Tiruchelvam, who was killed by an LTTE suicide bomb in July 1999. Those in the diaspora who continue to revere the memory of the LTTE must recognize that there should be no place for the glorification of such a ruthless organization.

I would like to pay my respects to all Sri Lankans, across the country, who were killed during those three decades of conflict, and offer my heartfelt sympathy to their families, all of whom – no matter who they are – share one thing: they have lost someone they can never replace. I have met many people during this visit whose relatives or spouses – both civilians and soldiers – are known to have been killed, or who are missing and may well be dead.

It is important everyone realizes that, although the fighting is over, the suffering is not.

I have been extremely moved by the profound trauma I have seen among the relatives of the missing and the dead, and the war survivors, in all the places I have visited, as well as by their resilience. This was particularly evident among those scratching out a living among the ghosts of burned and shelled trees, ruined houses and other debris of the final battle of the the war along the lagoon in Mullaitivu.

Wounds will not heal and reconciliation will not happen, without respect for those who grieve, and remembrance for the tens of thousands of Tamils, Sinhalese, Muslims and others who died before their time on the battlefield, in buses, on the street, or in detention. As one wife of a missing man put it poignantly: “Even when we eat, we keep a portion for him.”

Throughout my visit, the authorities, at all levels, have been keen to demonstrate to me how much has been achieved in terms of resettlement, reconstruction and rehabilitation in the relatively short period since the conflict with the LTTE ended in 2009. And the reconstruction achievements, made with the help of donor countries, UN agencies and NGOs, are indeed impressive: in both the Eastern and Northern Provinces, large numbers of new roads, bridges, houses, medical facilities and schools have been built or rebuilt; electricity and water supplies have been greatly improved; and most of the landmines have been removed. As a result, the great majority of the more than 450,000 people who were internally displaced at the end of the conflict have now gone home.

These are important achievements, and I understand the Government’s concern that they have perhaps not been sufficiently recognized. However, physical reconstruction alone will not bring reconciliation, dignity, or lasting peace. Clearly, a more holistic approach is needed to provide truth, justice and reparations for people’s suffering during the war, and I have repeated my previous offer of OHCHR’s assistance in these areas.

There are a number of specific factors impeding normalization, which – if not quickly rectified – may sow the seeds of future discord. These are by and large to do with the curtailment or denial of personal freedoms and human rights, or linked to persistent impunity and the failure of rule of law.

From the very beginning, I have placed great hopes in Sri Lanka achieving true peace and reconciliation after the war. I welcomed the LLRC report as an important step in that direction, even though it side-stepped the much-needed full, transparent, impartial investigation into the conduct of a conflict that saw numerous war crimes and other violations committed by both sides. The Human Rights Council has expressed a strong interest in seeing progress in the implementation of the most important LLRC recommendations, and proper investigation of the many outstanding allegations and concerns.

The LLRC report contains a broad range of excellent recommendations regarding concrete improvements on human rights, and I was interested to receive a briefing on the extent of the implementation of some of those recommendations from the Permanent Secretary to the President. My Office will closely examine that update and future developments in the implementation of the LLRC, and I will of course make reference to any genuine progress in my reports to the Human Rights Council.

I will now briefly outline some of the other issues that were raised during my visits to the Northern and Eastern Provinces, and which I have in turn raised with various ministers.

I welcome the forthcoming elections to the Northern Provincial Council and hope they will proceed in a peaceful, free and fair environment, and usher in an important new stage in the devolution of power.

I was concerned to hear about the degree to which the military appears to be putting down roots and becoming involved in what should be civilian activities, for instance education, agriculture and even tourism. I also heard complaints about the acquisition of private land to build military camps and installations, including a holiday resort. This is only going to make the complex land issues with which the Government has been grappling even more complicated and difficult to resolve. Clearly, the army needs some camps, but the prevalence and level of involvement of soldiers in the community seem much greater than is needed for strictly military or reconstruction purposes four years after the end of the war.

I understand the Secretary of Defence’s point that the demobilization of a significant proportion of such a large army cannot be done overnight, but urge the government to speed up its efforts to demilitarize these two war-affected provinces, as the continued large-scale presence of the military and other security forces is seen by many as oppressive and intrusive, with the continuing high level of surveillance of former combatants and returnees at times verging on harassment.

I was very concerned to hear about the vulnerability of women and girls, especially in female-headed households, to sexual harassment and abuse. I have raised this issue with several ministers, the provincial governors and senior military commanders who attended my meeting with the Secretary of Defence. I challenged them to rigorously enforce a zero tolerance policy for sexual abuse.

I have also been following up on the status of the remaining detainees and have urged the Government to expedite their cases, either by bringing charges or releasing them for rehabilitation. I also suggested it may now be time to repeal the Prevention of Terrorism Act which has long been cause for concern.

Because of the legacy of massive trauma, there is a desperate need for counseling and psychosocial support in the North, and I was surprised and disappointed to learn that the authorities have restricted NGO activity in this sector. I hope the Government can relax controls on this type of assistance.

I met many relatives of missing or disappeared civilians and soldiers who are still hoping to discover the whereabouts of their loved ones, and they emphasized the urgent need to resolve this issue – something that was made abundantly evident at the two very moving meetings with relatives of the disappeared that I attended yesterday, to commemorate the International Day of the Victims of Forced Disappearances.

I asked the Government for more information about the new Commission of Inquiry on Disappearances, and stressed the need for it to be more effective than the five previous commissions of this kind. I was disappointed to learn that it will only cover disappearances in the Northern and Eastern Provinces, which means that the many “white van” disappearances reported in Colombo and other parts of the country in recent years will not fall within its scope.

I urge the Government to broaden the Commission’s mandate, and seize this opportunity to make a comprehensive effort to resolve the disappearances issue once and for all. I therefore welcome the new proposal to criminalize disappearances in the penal code, and hope this will be done without delay. The Government could also send a clear signal of its commitment by ratifying the International Convention on Disappearances, and by inviting the Working Group on Enforced and Involuntary Disappearances to visit Sri Lanka, ideally before I report back to the Human Rights Council in March.

The Human Rights Council will also be looking to see something credible in terms of investigation of what happened at the end of the war and many other past cases.

I was pleased to learn that the case of the five students murdered on the beach in Trincomalee in 2006 has been reinvigorated by the arrest of 12 Police Special Task Force members known to have been in the vicinity at the time of the killings. I will be watching the progress of that case with interest, as well as the other infamous unsolved case of 17 ACF aid workers murdered in the same year, just a few kilometres to the south.

I also requested more information about the Courts of Inquiry appointed by the army to further investigate the allegations of civilian casualties and summary executions, and suggested that appointing the army to investigate itself does not inspire confidence in a country where so many past investigations and commissions of inquiry have foundered one way or another. Unless there is a credible national process, calls for an international inquiry are likely to continue.

The recent deployment of the military in support of police to control a demonstration in Welawariya, which resulted in at least three deaths, has sent a shockwave through the community. I stressed to the Defence Secretary the need to urgently complete and publish a proper investigation into this incident.

Too many other investigation files remain pending, for instance the custodial deaths of prisoners in Vavuniya and Welikada Prisons in 2012. The Government has since announced police powers will now be transferred from the Ministry of Defence to a new Ministry of Law and Order, but this is at best a partial separation as both Ministries will remain under the President, rather than under a separate civilian ministry.

I have also reminded the Government that Sri Lanka desperately needs strong witness and victim protection legislation, which has been languishing in draft form since 2007.

I expressed concern at the recent surge in incitement of hatred and violence against religious minorities, including attacks on churches and mosques, and the lack of swift action against the perpetrators. I was surprised that the Government seemed to downplay this issue, and I hope it will send the strongest possible signal of zero tolerance for such acts and ensure that those responsible (who are easily identifiable on video footage) are punished. The Minister of National Languages and Social Integration told me that he has proposed new legislation on hate speech. We have recently concluded a study of such laws and would be happy to assist in this area. The same Minister, along with the Minister of Justice, expressed to me his support for a visit by the Independent Expert on Minorities, and I hope this can happen as soon as possible. I also applaud the Government’s policy of introducing tri-lingualism all across the country.

I would now like to turn to a disturbing aspect of the visit, namely the harassment and intimidation of a number of human rights defenders, at least two priests, journalists, and many ordinary citizens who met with me, or planned to meet with me. I have received reports that people in villages and settlements in the Mullaitivu area were visited by police or military officers both before and after I arrived there. In Trincomalee, several people I met were subsequently questioned about the content of our conversation.

This type of surveillance and harassment appears to be getting worse in Sri Lanka, which is a country where critical voices are quite often attacked or even permanently silenced. Utterly unacceptable at any time, it is particularly extraordinary for such treatment to be meted out during a visit by a UN High Commissioner for Human Rights. I wish to stress that the United Nations takes the issue of reprisals against people because they have talked to UN officials as an extremely serious matter, and I will be reporting those that take place in connection with this visit to the Human Rights Council.

I urge the Government of Sri Lanka to issue immediate orders to halt this treatment of human rights defenders and journalists who face this kind of harassment and intimidation on a regular basis. More than 30 journalists are believed to have been killed since 2005, and several more – including the cartoonist Prageeth Ekneligoda ­– have disappeared. Many others have fled the country. Newspaper and TV offices have been vandalized or subjected to arson attacks – some, such as the Jaffna-based paper Uthayan, on multiple occasions. With self-censorship fuelled by fear, journalists report that there are articles that they dare not write, and others their editors dare not print. Freedom of expression is under a sustained assault in Sri Lanka. I have called for the right to Information Act to be adopted like many of its neighbours in SAARC.

The war may have ended, but in the meantime democracy has been undermined and the rule of law eroded. The 18th amendment, which abolished the Constitutional Council which once recommended appointments to the independent bodies, such as the Elections Commission and Human Rights Commission, has weakened these important checks and balances on the power of the Executive. The controversial impeachment of the Chief Justice earlier this year, and apparent politicization of senior judicial appointments, have shaken confidence in the independence of the judiciary.

I am deeply concerned that Sri Lanka, despite the opportunity provided by the end of the war to construct a new vibrant, all-embracing state, is showing signs of heading in an increasingly authoritarian direction.

Ending on a more optimistic note, yesterday, at the Government’s suggestion, I

visited the Youth Parliament. This unusual institution, founded in 2010, is filled with bright, enthusiastic students from all across the country, and dedicated to a tolerant and all-inclusive approach. The parliament draws on elected members of youth groups who meet once a month to discuss key issues such as the importance of Amendment 13 to the Constitution and the LLRC (indeed they claim they actually debated the latter before the National Parliament).

I hope that the current and future members of the Youth Parliament, three of whom delivered excellent speeches in my presence, will, when they graduate to the main political stage, usher in a new era of tolerant coexistence in this beautiful island, where – despite the problems I have listed above – I have been greeted with great warmth and hospitality.

Thank you.

புதன், 28 ஆகஸ்ட், 2013

Navi Pillay meeting Tamils in Jaffna ended in eyewash

Navi Pillay meeting Tamils in Jaffna ended in eyewash, say Tamil activists


The UN Human Rights Commissioner Navanetham Pillay met a group of 15 Tamil rights activists and civil representatives at the UN office in Jaffna. While she spent more time with the Sri Lankan State officials, the independent Tamil activists were given just 90 seconds each to present their cases under 8 different themes that included the cases of missing persons, detention of prisoners, land grab, colonization and attacks on religious institutions.

The rights activists said they were not provided enough time to make their cases and complained that the entire tour has ended as another eyewash or even farce.

The mother of Dilruxon, a Tamil youth, who was slain inside the prison in Vavuniyaa following a protest, narrated to Navi Pillay what had happened to her son in the Sri Lankan detention.

In the meantime, the SL military and the Colombo Establishment had brought Sinhala protestors to stage counter-protests in Jaffna.

The Sinhala gangs were held at standby at some halls in the city to launch counter-strikes.

But, as Navi Pillay didn’t reach out to the Tamil victims who had gathered in front of the Jaffna Public Library, the Sinhalese ‘protesters’ didn’t have an opportunity to stage any counter-protest, informed sources told TamilNet.

Chronology:

SL forces chase out Tamils waiting to see Navi Pillay

SL forces chase out Tamils waiting to see Navi Pillay in Vanni

[TamilNet, Wednesday, 28 August 2013, 00:47 GMT]
Sri Lankan military intelligence and SL policemen brutally attacked and chased out a group of 30 families and relatives of missing persons, who had gathered near Paranthan junction in Ki’linochchi district on Tuesday to express their message to the visiting UN Human Rights Commissioner Ms Navanetham Pillay. The families had come as they were told that Navi Pillay would be traveling through A9 on a visit to Mu’l’li-vaaykkaal from Jaffna. Commenting on the nature of the public response to Ms Pillai’s visit to the North, observers said that had Ban Ki Moon come, people wouldn’t have cared or even if they had gathered they wouldn’t have shed tears but would have responded differently.

When the UN Secretary General Ban ki Moon thought of ‘visiting’ the Tamils in the barbed wire camps after the war, they didn’t even want to stand up.

Commenting on the outcome of public response to Navi Pillai, the observers said that every renewed faith shown by people towards global organisations meant for humanity are thwarted by the Establishments of vicious agenda that have hijacked those organisations. The course of the case of Eezham Tamils is one such that has to be carefully perused by human civilisation in planning for future on what to do with the culprits of humanity, the Tamil observers further said.

In the meantime, a Colombo newspaper, The Island, on Wednesday, blatantly bared the genocide-shielding anxiety in the South, by reporting that the people who had gathered in Jaffna on Tuesday morning were “victims of LTTE violence” and the SL police only barricaded them off.

In Vanni, on Tuesday afternoon, the SL policemen and military intelligence officers attacked the gathering using batons.

Following the assault, the protesting families had to abandon their effort to express their feelings to the visiting UN Human Rights Commissioner.

Ms Navi Pillay, who took part in some events in Ki’linochchi visited Ve’l’laa-mu’l’livaaykkaal and left for Trincomalee, news sources in Vanni said.

Preparing for her visit, the occupying Sinhala military in a few days back removed all the remaining vestiges of war at Mu’l’li-vaaykkaal, such as abandoned vehicles etc., and dumped them elsewhere.

Chronology:


Related Articles:
23.06.09   Task of legal war vested with diaspora

Navi Pillay taken through backdoor

Navi Pillay taken through backdoor to avoid public in Jaffna

[TamilNet, Tuesday, 27 August 2013, 07:01 GMT]
Many among more than a thousand people gathered in front of the Jaffna Public Library on Tuesday morning to personally convey their feelings to the visiting UN Human Rights Commissioner Ms Navi Pillay, started shedding tears when they found out that Ms Pillay was taken away, through the backdoor, by the Sri Lankan officials. The gathering that was mostly the kith and kin of the people missing in the war and the aftermath, was told by the organisers of the visit to peacefully assemble in front of the Jaffna Public Library so that Ms Pillay would be seeing them. Some of the people had even travelled from the South to convey their bereavement. But, after meeting the SL Colonial Governor, SL Government Agents of the districts in the North and SL-run provincial council heads of departments at the Public Library hall, Ms Pillay was led through the backdoor.  



The visiting UN Human Rights Commissioner was scheduled to make a trip to witness the High Security Zone and to visit civil representatives in Jaffna.

But, in the last minute, the schedule has been completely changed, civil sources in Jaffna said.

Unable to meet Ms Navi Pillay, Kith and kin of missing shed tears


Unable to meet Ms Navi Pillay, Kith and kin of missing shed tears
Among the people standing outside the Public Library to convey their message to the visiting UN Human Rights Commissioner, there were also many Muslims whose relatives had gone missing in the South.

Ms Pillay was taken to the UN office at Nalloor Road where only a selected 15 people on behalf of the missing persons, would be meeting her. Every representative would be having 3 minute to present their case, the sources said.

Unable to meet Ms Navi Pillay, Kith and kin of missing shed tears


Ms Navi Pillay is scheduled to be taken to the bungalow of the SL Governor later today for lunch, the sources added.

A section of Colombo-based NGO personalities are also involved in changing the itinerary of the visiting UN Human Rights Commissioner, informed sources told TamilNet.

Unable to meet Ms Navi Pillay, Kith and kin of missing shed tears
Unable to meet Ms Navi Pillay, Kith and kin of missing shed tears

திங்கள், 25 பிப்ரவரி, 2013

International investigation essential - Navi Pillay

International investigation essential - Navi Pillay

[TamilNet, Sunday, 24 February 2013, 21:50 GMT]
UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Navaneetham Pillay, in an e-mail interview with Sunday Times, held steadfastedly to her belief that since the steps Sri Lanka has taken domestically has not inspired confidence, an International investigation into the crimes committed by both adversarial parties was essential for accountability, and to reconciliation. High Commissioner Pillay remained focused on the need to establish the truth of what happened during the final months of war while fending off the journalist's leading questions, and infused a fresh determination to establish accountability to the otherwise stiffling inaction of other International actors, Tamil political observers noted.
United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Navi Pillay
United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Navi Pillay
When asked why there is a need for another resolution [UNHCR] when the first one had "little impact," Pillay explained that "it is not that the resolution had little impact", but that the "Govt. [Sri Lankan] has made little progress in pursuing true accountability and reconciliation measures."

On the journalist's statement of Colombo's position that "such resolutions are impediments to reconciliation and its domestic programmes," Pillay said, while LTTE is a brutal organization, "[i]t is, nevertheless, important to address all situations where there have been massive HR violations, so that they are not brushed under the carpet....It is hard to see how real reconciliation will be possible, if the truth is not told, and if justice is not seen to be carried out.

On Navi Pillay "overreaching her mandate in expressing concern over impeachment of the Chief Justice," Pillay responded that her mandate is to "protect and promote the HR of everyone everywhere."

On the importance of calling for international war crimes investigation, Navi Pillay replied,
    Because tens of thousands of civilians were reportedly killed. Because there are very credible allegations and some strong pictorial evidence and witness accounts indicating that war crimes and other serious international crimes, including summary executions, use of child soldiers and the use of civilians as human shields took place on a large scale.

    These are crimes that are viewed with the utmost seriousness under international human rights and humanitarian law, and there is plenty of evidence to suggest both sides committed them. Unfortunately, none of the steps taken domestically in Sri Lanka, to investigate any of this, inspire confidence. There is a long history of national inquiries in Sri Lanka that have led nowhere, but to impunity. This makes such an international investigation essential. Crimes like these cannot simply be ignored or pushed aside. If there has been exaggeration or distortions, or unjust allegations, then such an inquiry should also expose those. There has to be justice, if there is to be lasting peace.
When Sunday Times mentioned that "perhaps there is little appetite for an investigation," because the war ended 3 years ago and there are several other crises in the world, Pillay's response was that "there is actually increasing appetite, as people start to see more details of what happened."

When prompted to comment on the "little local interest" in war crimes investigation, Pillay replied, among other factors, "Tamil population in Sri Lanka, especially in the war-affected parts of the country, must be treated fairly. They went through a quite atrocious experience. Crimes committed against them must be investigated, just like crimes committed by the LTTE."

Sunday Times mentions a curious form of "torture." The HRC is genuinely accused of double standards vis-a-vis Sri Lanka, and some other pro-Western countries (for instance, Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Yemen, Occupied Territories). Is this exercise merely to inflict continuing diplomatic torture on Sri Lanka, until they fall in line with the West?

Pillay points out that "None of the countries mention[ed] has gone through a conflict like the one in Sri Lanka."

When Sunday Times asks if there is an "orchestrated conspiracy" against Sri Lanka, and if this is fair, Pillay educates the journalist not to confuse conspiracy with campaigns. And adds, "I am not at all surprised that there are campaigns being carried out by HR activists, for all the reasons we have discussed already. This is a symptom of the fact that there has not yet been a proper independent and credible investigation into all the HR violations that took place during the conflict, with the aim of bringing sorely needed justice and reparations."

Sunday Times then claims that the State "has engaged with the UN system consistently and transparently," and hence expects reciprocity, Pillay's reply implies that her engagement with Sri Lanka is more than satisfactory.

On why UNHCR's approach to Sri Lanka is not cooperation but confrontational, Pillay replies that she looks for "cooperation with all govts., but, at the same time, my mandate also involves acting as the voice of the victims, and speaking out when needed."

External Links:
ST: Govt. efforts at investigating alleged war crimes lack credibility: NP

புதன், 13 பிப்ரவரி, 2013

Navi Pillay precludes ‘procedures’

Navi Pillay precludes ‘procedures’ to adopt by UNHRC process

[TamilNet, Tuesday, 12 February 2013, 22:46 GMT]
While the US officials, who visited the island of Sri Lanka last month, were talking of tabling a ‘procedural resolution’ to approach affairs of the island at the March sessions of the UNHRC in Geneva, the report that has come from the office of Ms Navi Pillai (OHCHR) on Monday outlined what procedures have to be taken to further the processes started with last year’s resolution at the UNHRC. When the US-tabled resolution, watered down by India and passed last year, was fundamentally responsible for the acceleration of structural genocide of Eezham Tamils as witnessed in the course of the year, any further ‘procedural’ enhancement of the resolution is like decorating the rat’s tail with a silk tassel, as the saying in Tamil goes (eli vaalukku padduk kungncham), commented human rights activists in Jaffna.
Navi Pillay, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights
Navi Pillay, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights
Ms. Navi Pillay is the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights and heads the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR).

The United Nations Human Rights Council (UNHRC) is a UN body of 47 elected countries, the sessions of which are facilitated and convened by the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights.

Upholding Colombo’s genocidal blueprint of the LLRC as “significant and far-reaching”, the report by the OHCHR observed that the Government of Sri Lanka has made “significant progress in rebuilding infrastructure”.

However, the report identified that the commitment for implementation of LLRC findings had come only on selected recommendations.

It also said that the Colombo government had not adequately engaged civil society in support of a “more consultative and inclusive reconciliation process”.

On investigation of alleged serious violations of human rights, the steps taken by Sri Lanka have been “inconclusive, and lack the independence and impartiality required to inspire confidence”, the report said.

The report urged urgency of action to combat impunity, pointing out reports of “extrajudicial killings, abductions and enforced disappearances”.

The report was harping on the “establishment of a truth-seeking mechanism as an integral part of a more comprehensive and inclusive approach to transitional justice”.

Shallowly dealing with recent manifestations of congenital issues in the island, the report suggested to “engage civil society and minority community representatives in dialogue on appropriate forms of commemoration and memorialization that will advance inclusion and reconciliation.”

On the crux of the matter, elusive to solutions in the island for ages, the report restricted itself only to taking “further steps in demilitarization and devolution to involve minority communities fully in decision-making processes.”

The report concluded by citing the stand of Ms Navi Pillai that “In this regard, she reaffirms her long-standing call for an independent and credible international investigation into alleged violations of international human rights and humanitarian law, which could also monitor any domestic accountability process.”

* * *

While what crisis that has taken the island to the international scrutiny is a national question and is a question of genocide, the approach and procedural suggestions viewing it as something not connected to the questions, but to connected to all-island structural issues, is a fundamentally deviatory and a knowingly wrong machination repeated over the ages due to the Power interests.

As a body of United Nations and not as a body of the United Establishments of the world, the OHCHR report has failed in its duty to tell the humanity of our times the real nature of the issue and the possible impact of it to entire humanity in allowing Power interests to twist and hijack the issue, commented Tamil human rights activists in the island.

The Navi Pillay report of the OHCHR will be presented along with the report of the UN Secretary General and the annual report of the UNHRC, under Agenda item 2 of the 22nd session of the UNHRC at Geneva in March.

When the so-called International Organisation, conceived to be rising above the Establishments and the nation-states of the world, could not able to see and talk of explicit realities in the island, the existence and non-existence of the organisation matters nothing to the serious minded of the next generation that cares for shaping humanity’s future, commented new generation Tamil activists in the island.


Chronology:

திங்கள், 17 செப்டம்பர், 2012

Sri Lanka in UN list of countries accused of intimidating critics

Sri Lanka in UN list of countries accused of intimidating critics

[TamilNet, Sunday, 16 September 2012, 12:47 GMT]
Sri Lanka has been included in the the United Nations list of 16 nations singled out for cracking down on critics, the Washington Post reported. The UN report added that most of those countries’ governments are going unpunished for their acts of reprisal. U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay told a special session of the Human Rights Council that the 16 nations detailed in a new report “have been far from sufficient” in preventing members of their own governments from resorting to intimidation and attacks on various activists, the Post further said.

The other 15 countries, named in the UN report covering mid-June 2011 to mid-July 2012, are: Algeria, Bahrain, Belarus, China, Colombia, Iran, Kazakhstan, Kenya, Lebanon, Malawi, Rwanda, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Uzbekistan and Venezuela.

 Navi Pillay
United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Navi Pillay
U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay told the UN Rights session, “Reprisals and intimidation against individuals continue to be reported. People may be threatened or harassed by government officials, including through public statements by high-level authorities. Associations and NGOs may see their activities monitored or restricted.

"Smear campaigns against those who cooperate with the U.N. may be organized. Threats may be made via phone calls, text messages or even direct contacts. People may also be arrested, beaten or tortured and even killed,” Washington Post quoted Navi Pillay as saying.

While urging the UN Rights Council and the world's nations to do more to combat alleged cases of killings, beatings, torture, arrests, threats, harassment and smear campaigns against human rights defenders, Navi Pillay further said, “[w]e need more coherent and solid strategies to put an end to reprisals. Reprisals are not only unacceptable: they are also ineffective in the long term. Preventing people from expressing their will or their dissent freely, does not succeed. Ultimately, freedom will always prevail. And information will always find its way to the outside word."

External Links:
WP: UN singles out 16 countries, including Bahrain, for government reprisals against critics


திங்கள், 9 ஜனவரி, 2012

No amnesty for war-criminals

No amnesty for war-criminals, says UN's 

Navi Pillay

[TamilNet, Sunday, 08 January 2012, 04:01 GMT]
Granting amnesty to perpetrators of war crimes and human rights abuses under Yemen's presidential power transition deal would be against international law, the United Nations human rights chief said on Friday, undermining the peace agreement, Reuters reported. The implications of this to pending litigation of sitting and ex-Presidents in courts around the world are significant according to legal sources in Washington. Professor Francis Boyle commented that while the UN pronouncements were directed towards Yemen, for bringing the culpable Sri Lanka leaders to justice for crimes committed during the Mu'l'livaaykkaal massacre, continued action outside Sri Lanka by Tamil expatriates was crucial.

Professor Boyle in a note sent to TamilNet said: "The GOSL [Government of Sri Lanka] are so brazen in their genocidal criminality that they are not even going to bother giving themselves “amnesty.” They will continue to tough it out and figure they can get away with it forever. So far every government in the world including and especially India has let them do so, as well as the United Nations Organization. It is up to us People to turn the situation around and hold the GOSL accountable. 50,000 massacred Tamils in Vanni demand no less of our Common Humanity!"

Noting that Pillay has previously blamed Yemeni government forces for using live ammunition against unarmed protesters and has said President Ali Abdullah Saleh should not get amnesty in a deal to persuade him to leave power, Reuters summarized Navi Pillay's statement as follows:

    "I have been closely following the events in Yemen, particularly the very contentious debate about an amnesty law to be presented to Parliament shortly," "International law and the U.N. policy are clear on the matter: amnesties are not permissible if they prevent the prosecution of individuals who may be criminally responsible for international crimes including war crimes, crimes against humanity, genocide, and gross violations of human rights." "Based on information we have gathered, there is reason to believe that some of these crimes were committed in Yemen during the period for which an amnesty is under consideration. Such an amnesty would be in violation of Yemen's international human rights obligations,"
Saudi Arabia has supported Saleh by donating diesel and crude oil and the United States, which long backed Saleh as a pillar of its "counter-terrorism" strategy, helped craft the power transition deal giving him immunity from prosecution, Reuters report said.

External Links:
Reuters: UN's Pillay: Yemen peace-deal amnesty may be unlawful