ICC லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி
ICC லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி

ஞாயிறு, 8 டிசம்பர், 2013

ICC's failure to prosecute Sri Lanka

ICC's failure to prosecute Sri Lanka, no shelter to Africa's criminals, says HRW

[TamilNet, Saturday, 07 December 2013, 19:42 GMT]
African leaders are raising concern over the actions of the 11-year old court of last resort, the International Criminial Court (ICC), where the eight cases that are currently active, and the twenty-one defendents in those cases are all from Africa, Washington Post reported Sunday. The article quoted Richard Dicker from Human Rights who countered Africa's arguments saying that African nations cannot deny access to victims (in Darfur or Kenya) just because it is not possible to provide victims in Sri Lanka justice, implying that while ICC has failed to go after war-criminals in Sri Lanka even after the UN's Petrie Report has accused Sri Lanka of killing more than 70,000 Tamil civilians in the no-fire zone, this is not sufficient to deny african victims redress through the Court.

African leaders say that comparable crimes elsewhere in the world are being ignored and that race is a factor in the decision-making. With Kenya’s president and deputy president on trial, African leaders are pushing for changes that some ICC advocates say would undermine the court completely, the Washington Post said in its ICC coverage.
The ICC has not shown any inclination to investigate Palitha Kohona, an Australian citizen of Sri Lankan origin who has been charged with complicity to genocide in papers filed with the ICC. Australia is a signatory to Rome Statute which provides jurisdiction to the ICC to prosecute Australians for war-crimes.

In 2009, Bruce Fein, counsel for a US-based Tamil activist group Tamils Against Genocide (TAG), in a letter sent to Chief Prosecutor at the International Criminal Court (ICC) Hon. Luis Moreno-Ocampo, urging him to open investigations for war crimes, crimes against humanity and war crimes against four high-level officials of the Sri Lanka Government, and received no response.

O'Campo earlier initimated to a CNN reporter that since Sri Lanka is not a signatory to the Rome Statute ICC does not have jurisdiction to investigate Sri Lanka crimes. Only the UN Security Council should provide the mandate to the UN Chief Prosecutor to indict Sri Lanka, or the Secretary General should establish a tribunal similar to what was established for Yugoslavia and Rwanda.

Related Articles:
12.01.13   Nambiar, India's proxy in UN, complicit in white flag killin..
28.12.12   Takasu, Tamils' adversary in UN Security Council?
19.12.12   Holmes, UN's smokescreen to Mu'l'livaaykkaal killings?
13.02.11   TAG, SCET's legal brief asserts ICC obligated to probe Kohon..
08.12.10   Dual citizen Kohona falls under ICC jurisdiction on War Crim..
21.06.10   Intoxicating hubris
16.02.10   UN rights chief says lack of progress in Sri Lanka investiga..
04.05.09   Ocampo urged to investigate Sri Lanka's war crimes
15.02.09   Genocide in Sri Lanka - Boston Globe
20.08.08   Sri Lanka officials complicit in Tamil Genocide? - Washingto..


External Links:
WP: African leaders complain of bias at ICC as Kenya trials get underway

புதன், 24 ஜூலை, 2013

UN Sri Lanka tribunal will avoid ICC jurisdictional

UN Sri Lanka tribunal will avoid ICC jurisdictional issues, says Boyle

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=IWfHr3GsddE
 [TamilNet, Tuesday, 23 July 2013, 00:43 GMT]
The United Nations General Assembly (GA) must immediately establish an International Criminal Tribunal for Sri Lanka (ICTSL) as a "subsidiary organ" under U.N. Charter Article 22, and organized along the lines of the International Criminal Tribunal for Yugoslavia (ICTY), which was established by the Security Council, said Professor Francis Boyle, an expert in International Law, while commenting on the appointment of Samantha Power as the U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations, and advocating that Ms Power should follow the leadership of Madeline Albright who spearheaded the setting up of the ICTY. This will avoid the jurisdictional hurdles in the ICC taking up criminal matters related to a non-signatory state, Boyle added.

Albright on the establishment of ICTY
The purpose of the ICTSL would be to investigate and prosecute Sri Lanka war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide against the Peoples of Lebanon and Palestine--just as the ICTY did for the victims of international crimes committed by Serbia and the Milosevic Regime throughout the Balkans, Professor Boyle said.

According to Boyle, the establishment of ICTSL would provide some small degree of justice to the victims of Sri Lanka's war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide against the Tamil people in NorthEast--just as the ICTY has done in the Balkans. Furthermore, the establishment of ICTSL by the U.N. General Assembly would serve as a deterrent effect upon Sri Lanka's polical leaders such as Sri Lanka's President Mahinda Rajapakse, his sibling and Defense Secretary, Gothabaya Rajapakse, another brother and minister for Development, Basil Rajapakse, Military Commander Sarath Fonseka and other top generals that they will be prosecuted for their further infliction of international crimes upon the Tamils from the NorthEast of Sri Lanka, Professor Boyle said.

Behind the scenes of ICTY
Tamil political activists agreed that without such a deterrent, Sri Lanka will likely continue the cultural genocide including forced colonization, grabing land from Tamil civilians, and militarization of day-to-day life and engaging the military in civilian affairs.

"For the U.N. General Assembly to establish ICTSL could stop the further development of this momentum towards a regional if not global catastrophe," Boyle added.

"People need to understand that Power could push for an International Criminal Tribunal for Sri Lanka on the basis of UN Charter article 22 to be set up by the UN General Assembly, thus avoiding the jurisdictional problems with the International Criminal Court since Sri Lanka is not a party and it appears that China would veto any referral by the Security Council to the ICC," Boyle further said.

"The UN General Assembly could take the Statute for the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda and transform it into the Statute for the International Criminal Tribunal for Sri Lanka," Professor Boyle said.

Francis A. Boyle is a graduate of the University of Chicago and Harvard Law School. He has advised numerous international bodies in the areas of human rights, war crimes, genocide, nuclear policy, and bio warfare. He received a PHD in political science from Harvard University.

External Links:
UN:International Criminal Tribunal Rwanda: ICTR
ICTY:International Criminal Tribunal for Yugoslavia
ICTY:Karadzic, Mladic indictment
UN:Charter of the United Nations
Gen:Cambodia Tribunal

திங்கள், 1 ஏப்ரல், 2013

ICC's focus on Africa examined

ICC's focus on Africa examined

[TamilNet, Sunday, 31 March 2013, 14:04 GMT]
Defining the International Criminal Court (ICC) in glowing terms, Kofi Annan said 15 years ago, after the Rome Statute was drafted in Rome, “Until now, when powerful men committed crimes against humanity, they knew that so long as they remained powerful, no earthly court could judge them." But, American University professor David Bosco asks, "[a]fter more than a decade, all eight investigations the court has opened have been in Africa. All the individuals indicted by the court — more than two dozen — have been African. Annan’s proclamation notwithstanding, some very powerful people in other parts of the world have avoided investigation," and mentions Sri Lanka as one of the countries that escapes ICC scrutiny, in the latest Sunday edition of the Washington Post.
Former African Union (A.U.) chairman Jean Ping has suggested to journalists that the court is a neocolonial plaything and that “Africa has been a place to experiment with their ideas.” At an African summit meeting in 2009, Ping accused the ICC of ignoring crimes in other parts of the world: “Why Africa only? Why were these laws not applied on Israel, Sri Lanka and Chechnya and its application is confined to Africa?” Boscoe notes.

African leaders have taken note of the ICC’s intense interest resulting in swelling backlash after the court indicted Sudanese President Omar Hassan al-Bashir in 2009, and the African Union with nearly 50 member nations, even instructed its members that they had no legal obligation to arrest Bashir.

Bosco notes that to this day, the A.U. has refused to allow the ICC to establish a liaison office at its headquarters, and that there are even plans for an African criminal court that might displace the ICC.

Bosco says complaints on ICC's approach to prosecution land mostly on the desk of the court’s prosecutor, Fatou Bensouda. Originally from Gambia, she was elected in December 2011 with strong support from African states and has made repairing the rift between the court and the continent a priority. Along the way, she has fired back at some of the court’s African critics, insisting that seeking justice for victims on the continent is hardly evidence of discrimination, Bosco writes.

Commenting on the June 2012 sentencing of Charles Taylor by the UN's Special Court for Sierra Leone (SC-SL) for 50 years and the ruling by the UN's International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR) giving life imprisonment to Rwanda's Nzabonimana, Professor Boyle, an expert in International Law, who teaches at the University of Illinois College of Law, told TamilNet, that UN's "International Criminal Court (ICC) has become a joke and a fraud. I supported it originally. But no more. It has no credibility whatsoever. It [ICC] just goes after tin-pot dictators in Africa while real war criminals such as Bush...get off scot-free... I am keeping Rajapaksas et al on my list of things to do," Boyle said.

Commenting on the enforced disappearances of human beings that are widespread and systematic in Sri Lanka, Boyle said these are a Crime against Humanity under the Rome Statute for the International Criminal Court (ICC). "So if Gotobhaya Rajapakse travels to an ICC Member State, it might be possible to get him prosecuted in the visiting country under its domestic implementing legislation for the Rome Statute," Boyle said, on the possibilities of how ICC can scare off genocidaires from travelling freely across the world.

Related Articles:
26.12.12   Systemic disappearances qualify as crimes against humanity i..
03.06.12   ICC a fraud, goes only after Africa's tin-pot dictators, say..
16.02.10   UN rights chief says lack of progress in Sri Lanka investiga..


External Links:
Wikipedia: Niccolò Machiavelli
AA: A Talk with ICC Prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo
ICC: BAshir: Case Information Sheet
ICC: Rome Statute of the ICC
ICC: Bashir: ICC Prosecutor's Article 58 Application for Arrest Warrant
IWPR: Playing Politics With the ICC
ICC: ICC Prosecutor presents case against Sudanese President, Hassan Ahmad AL BASHIR, for genocide, crimes against humanity and war crimes in Darfur
WP: Why is the International Criminal Court picking only on Africa?
ICC: ICC's Application for Warrant of Arrest Against AL BASHIR
ICC: The Prosecutor


வியாழன், 27 டிசம்பர், 2012

Systemic disappearances qualify as crimes against humanity in ICC, says Boyle

Systemic disappearances qualify as crimes against humanity in ICC, says Boyle

[TamilNet, Wednesday, 26 December 2012, 22:46 GMT]
The enforced disappearances of human beings that are widespread and systematic, such as the abductions of Tamils in the NorthEast including the midnight abduction of 28-year-old Mrs Soundararajan Sivamalar in Uduvil, Jaffna, on Christmas eve by Sri Lanka's Terrorism Division, are a Crime against Humanity under the Rome Statute for the International Criminal Court (ICC), Professor Boyle of the University of Illinois College of Law said. "So if Gotobhaya travels to an ICC Member State, it might be possible to get him prosecuted in the visiting country under its domestic implementing legislation for the Rome Statute," Boyle said.

Spokesperson for Tamils Against Genocide (TAG), a US-based activist group said, "While we are fighting to overturn the protection given to the primary genocidaire, Mahinda Rajapakse, by the United States Department of State under the extra-legal and discretionary application of the doctrine of Head of State Immunity, we will not have a similar issue with sibling Gotabhaya Rajakapakse, when he travels to a ICC signatory state," TAG said.

Boyle added, "under the ICC Rome Statute, it is a requirement that member states enact domestic implementing legislation making ICC Rome Statute Crimes domestic crimes as well. Hence it might be possible to prosecute Gotobaya under these domestic ICC Crimes even if the ICC does not have jurisdiction.

"This is how the objectors scared President Bush out of traveling to Switzerland by demanding his prosecution if he showed up there under their domestic implementing legislation for the ICC even though the USA is not a party to the Rome Statute," Boyle added.

Most of Europe now has domestic implementing legislation for the ICC. International Criminal Court Act No. 41, 2002 facilitates compliance by Australia with obligations under the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, and for related purposes.

Chronology:


Related Articles:
25.12.12   Sri Lanka’s terror abductions, arrests, summons mark Christm..
17.12.12   40 ex-LTTE members abducted within one week, IOM, UN blamed ..
21.06.10   Intoxicating hubris

புதன், 6 ஜூன், 2012

ICC a fraud, goes only after Africa's tin-pot dictators, says Boyle

ICC a fraud, goes only after Africa's tin-pot dictators, says Boyle

[TamilNet, Sunday, 03 June 2012, 00:09 GMT]
Commenting on the recent sentencing of Charles Taylor by the UN's Special Court for Sierra Leone (SC-SL) for 50 years and the ruling by the UN's International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR) giving life imprisonment to Rwanda's Nzabonimana, Professor Boyle, an expert in International Law, who teaches at the University of Illinois College of Law, told TamilNet, that UN's "International Criminal Court (ICC) has become a joke and a fraud. I supported it originally. But no more. It has no credibility whatsoever. It [ICC] just goes after tin-pot dictators in Africa while real war criminals such as Bush...get off scot-free... I am keeping Rajapaksas et al on my list of things to do," Boyle said.

Tamil circles, while not disagreeing with this harsh assessment of the U.N., say that the sheer weight of Sri Lanka's brutality amounting to genocide will ultimately force the UN to take action against the ruling Rajapaksa family and Sri Lanka, if the diaspora and the rights organizations are successful in keeping the memory of the Mu'l'livaaykkaal massacre alive.

Charles Taylor, former President of Liberia
Charles Taylor, former President of Liberia
Judge Lussick, an Australian-born Samoan, and two other judges calling the crimes committed by Charles Taylor, the former president of Liberia, in the neighbouring country of Sierra Leone as “some of the most heinous and brutal crimes recorded in human history,” sentenced the 64-year old Taylor that will exceed his life span.

Abetting mass murder, rape and amputation is a truly extraordinary crime deserving an extraordinary punishment, and the court took the position that Mr. Taylor’s status as a head of state at the time of the offences was an aggravating factor; a public trust had been betrayed, said Canada's Globe and Mail.

"Any head of state or government should take pause before authorizing aid to armed factions in civil wars which may turn out to be viciously barbarous. Presidents and prime ministers should long remember Charles Taylor," the paper warned.

Callixte Nzabonimana, former Rwandan youth minister
Callixte Nzabonimana, former Rwandan youth minister
Meanwhile, within a week after the Taylor judgement, the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR) found former Rwandan youth minister Callixte Nzabonimana guilty of playing a key role in the genocide, conspiracy, incitement and extermination of nearly 800,000 minority Tutsis and politically moderate Hutus in 100 days between April and June 1994.

A meeting held in the town of Murambi, in the central Gitarama province led to "an agreement" between Nzabonimana and other ministers "to encourage the killing of Tutsis... with the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, the Tutsi population as such in Gitarama prefecture," the AFP said referring to the court's verdict.

External Links:
CSM: My final phone call with warlord Charles Taylor
BBC: Rwanda's Calllixte Nzabonimana gets life for genocide
G&M: Charles Taylor’s 50-year sentence is well justified