Justice Wigneswaran லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி
Justice Wigneswaran லேபிளுடன் இடுகைகளைக் காண்பிக்கிறது. அனைத்து இடுகைகளையும் காண்பி

ஞாயிறு, 28 ஏப்ரல், 2013

Justice Wigneswaran delivers ITAK’s Chelva Memorial Lecture

Justice Wigneswaran delivers ITAK’s Chelva Memorial Lecture

[TamilNet, Sunday, 28 April 2013, 07:01 GMT]
Marking the 36th death anniversary of S.J.V. Chelvanayagam Q.C., Justice C.V. Wigneswaran delivered this year’s Thanthai Chelvanayagam Memorial Lecture, titled “Wither Sri Lankan Tamils,” at the New Kathiresan Hall in Colombo on Friday. The Lecture was organised by the Colombo District Branch of the Ilankai Tamil Arasu Kadchi (ITAK), formerly known in English as Federal Party and is currently the leading constituent party of the Tamil National Alliance (TNA). Justice Wigneswaran’s lecture gains significance, as there are speculations about TNA fielding him as Chief Minister in the Geneva Resolution-urged Northern Provincial Council elections. Despite logic and eloquence in aptly bringing out the cause of Tamils, the lecture was ultimately reeking of the agenda of India and the USA, political observers in the island commented.
C.V. Wigneswaran
Former SC Judge CV Wigneswaran [Photo courtesy: Daily Mirror]
Justice Wigneswaran compared the non-implementation of the 13th Amendment by Colombo to the abrogation of the Banda-Chelva pact and the Dudley-Chelva pact.

He brought out the history of cheat committed on Tamils, once the Sinhala leaders achieved their purposes in the past with the help of Tamils. He traced it back to the times of Sir P. Arunachalam. “Muslims are the latest group of minorities taught that lesson,” he said.

According to him, the SL government is reluctant to hold the provincial elections for the North, even four years after the war, because of the fear that a democratically elected PC would affect the powers of the “Central Government.” He used the federal terminology, Central Government, even though the PC model created under a unitary constitution doesn’t justify it.

There was also a luring hint in his lecture that a democratically elected Northern PC could call for the withdrawal of the Governor coming from the SL military service, and the PC could also call for garrisoning the SL military in barracks.

The Eastern Provincial Council elections took place in May 2008. The USA and India blessed it.

Every one knows the extent of ‘democratic’ manipulations, militarisation, colonisation and the accelerated structural genocide that have taken place in the East under the ‘democratically’ elected Eastern Provincial Council in the last five years.

But no one asks the USA and India about their logic behind sticking to the same model for the North too, and their logic in internationally binding the solutions to Tamils to the PC election, even in forums like the UNHRC, commented Tamil alternative political activists in the island.

Wigneswaran was briefing the history of cheat faced by Tamils, every time after the Sinhala polity fulfilled its agenda. But are we not going to learn from it in facing today’s context of possible cheat coming from the USA and India, once their agenda is fulfilled after making Tamils agree to their ‘reconciliation’ deception, the political activists in the island asked.

While there is a powerful demand from several quarters for the IC to bring in an internationally organised interim administration for Eezham Tamils in the island, in order to stop the on-going structural genocide, TNA parliamentarian Mr. Suresh Premachandran was demanding ‘international monitoring’ of the Northern PC elections.

Justice Wigneswaran implying positively on the Northern PC has to be read along with Suresh Premachandran’s call for international monitoring, political observers said.

* * *

Justice Wigneswaran was logical and eloquent on the cause of Tamils in the island. Tamils in the island were never a minority, but were made a minority, he said.

“It was when the evil genius of a foreign conqueror subdued the whole island with its separate and sovereign people, pulled down age-old national frontiers and for no other reason than his own ‘supervisory convenience’ made the island a single political and administrative unit that the Tamils became a minority […],” he cited M. Vythilingam.

He cited Chelvanayagam talking of “genocide against the Tamils,” in 1974 itself to the CHOGM delegates who had come to Colombo.

In his lecture, Justice Wigneswaran brought out the entire dimensions of the past and present genocide as well as the future agenda of the Sinhala polity in a nutshell.

He also asserted on historical sovereignty and remedial sovereignty of Tamils, even though he has not mentioned them by name.

He cautioned the Sri Lankan State that, “The very repression adopted to prevent a clamour for separation, might give rise to the International Community becoming convinced that separation is the only solution to the Group affected. The ground situation could convince them that external self determination is to be preferred to internal self determination in the light of what they observe.”

Gaining the confidence of the majority community by the tactic of denouncing separatism has not worked, he said citing especially the current plight of Muslims. He said that he fully endorses the view of the TNA in not joining the bandwagon in a Parliamentary Select Committee for talks without working documents to start with.

Justice Wigneswaran was saintly in talking on the unity of Tamil people, unity of Tamil political parties, exclusivism that relegated an inferior and insulting position to a section of our people, the Karmig boomerang, collective approach, engaging with the Sinhalese people to educate them on shared history and on the injustices meted out to Tamils etc.

He made a valuable observation on accepting the injustice caused to the Muslims and forging solidarity with them.

* * *

However, the latter part of the lecture of Justice Wigneswaran implied that he was telling all the above just for the ‘reconciliation’ process with non-descript solutions and without bearings, alternative Tamil political activists in the island commented.

Further comments from them follow:

The only well-defined bearing in the lecture was once again ‘treading the failed beaten path’ shown by the Establishments in retaining the unity of the State in the island.

But he was critical of Tamils bent on continuing to tread the beaten path and one of them was the path of separatism.

He was careful in avoiding the word Eezham and was asserting to the identity “we Sri Lankan Tamils,” while in his ancestral district Trincomalee the occupying Sinhala military was assaulting people of the village Ilangkaith-thu’rai for even uttering the word Ilangkai in the name of their village; demanding them to say “Lanka-patuna” instead.

Like the ICG reports, he detracted the diaspora polity. He implied scepticism on expecting anything positive from the feelings prevailing in Tamil Nadu.

Pre-empting any mobilisation of masses addressing against the ultimate culprits, he painted a rosy picture that the International Community has just now only realised the diabolical and double-tongued nature of Colombo’s polity.

Detracting Tamils from internationalising their cause for liberation, he was harping on agitations for internal self-determination.

He called for the diaspora to contribute to ‘development’.

He was talking of meeting legal challenges faced by affected individuals, challenging illegal state ventures, seeking justice for those who lost all during the war, pursuing accountability of those who caused it etc., and ‘internationalising’ only such issues.

Encouraging Tamils to fight by counting trees, but politically tiring them by giving time and space to the Sri Lankan State to create more trees, ultimately to make Tamils to compromise with the larger issue of their own structural genocide is the on-going game now, commented the political activists, citing that all what was said in the latter part of the Justice’s lecture was nothing but what the Establishments that waged the war against Eezham Tamils had told them after the war.

The Lecture only shows that in his intellectual prowess, skills and approach, the Colombo-born-bred and educated retired Justice Wigneswaran could easily surpass any one currently in the TNA, or for that matter any one currently ‘articulating’ in the diaspora polity, in insinuating Tamils with the agenda of the Establishments, the alternative political activists further commented.

ஞாயிறு, 18 டிசம்பர், 2011

Former SC judge sceptical of solution without internal or external pressure

Former SC judge sceptical of solution without internal or external pressure

[TamilNet, Friday, 16 December 2011, 23:32 GMT]
“I do not see any possible solution to the ethnic conflict immediately, unless extraneous pressure, inland or foreign, compels the powers that be to relent,” said former Supreme Court Judge CV Wigneswaran in giving an interview to Colombo-based Daily Mirror, Thursday. Justice Wigneswaran’s interview gains significance in the light of Sri Lanka’s ‘leaked’ LLRC report, coming out with a blue print for completing structural genocide by 2020, accuses Tamils seeking international remedy as counterproductive. Justice Wigneswaran’s interview, dealing in detail with the past deceits of Sinhala polity, also corresponds with Prof. Sitrampalam’s concerns over Colombo-centric elements in Tamil polity once again leading Tamils into a trap and with the recent Tamil civil society admonition to the leadership of the Tamil National Alliance (TNA).

C.V. Wigneswaran
Former SC Judge CV Wigneswaran [Photo courtesy: Daily Mirror]
“I do not see any possible solution to the ethnic conflict immediately, unless extraneous pressure, inland or foreign, compels the powers that be to relent. This applies to both the government as well as the opposition. Majority community parties are not interested in any solution and want to maintain the supremacy of the majority community through their language and religion. Except for a handful of persons like Dr. Wickramabahu Karunaratne, Mr.Weliamuna and a few others the majority of Sinhala masses do not want a solution, “ Justice Wigneswaran said in the interview to Daily Mirror’s Ayesha Zuhair on Thursday.

The following are further elucidations of Justice Wigneswaran on his point:

Let me explain why I make such a sweeping statement.

Around 1919, the Sinhalese leaders found that unless they made their request for territorial representation unanimously the British were not going to grant their request. So they approached Sir P. Arunachalam, gave him written undertaking that a seat would be reserved for the Tamils in Colombo, and requested him to talk to the Jaffna Association, which preferred communal representation to territorial representation.

In the cause of creating a well-knit united Ceylonese polity he was able to get the Jaffna Association to consent to territorial representation. He had implicit trust in the Sinhalese leaders.

The request to the Queen was thereafter unanimous and the 1921 Constitution granted their request for territorial representation. Once the supremacy of the majority community was ensured in the Legislature the Sinhalese leaders Sir James Peiris and E.J.Samarawickreme retracted.

A seat for Tamils in Colombo was refused. The reason they gave was significant. Apart from saying that they were not bound by their written promise since they no longer held the offices they earlier held when promising, they also said “You Tamils are yourselves the majority in your two provinces. Why should you have seats in Colombo?”

This meant they recognised the individuality of the Ceylonese Tamil Community who had occupied the two provinces, North and East, from pre-historic times.

It was such recognition that made S.W.R.D. Bandaranaike passing out from the Oxford University to recommend a federal constitution for Ceylon. The Tamils did not accept this idea favourably since they were scattered throughout the island while being rooted in the North and East and were doing well.

Thereafter the majority community made use of the whip-hand they had got by virtue of the legal instrument of territorial representation, to discriminate against the minorities especially the Tamils. Under the Donoughmore Constitution the numerical strength of the majority community led to the formation of the Pan Sinhala Cabinet.

After the Pan Sinhala Government of the 1930s we see them depriving the franchise of the Up Country Tamils in the 1940s. Then in the 1950s the Sinhala Only Act deprived many Tamils of their government jobs. Early 1970s saw standardisation in education, which deprived many Tamils of their higher education.

Throughout this period the state was colonising areas traditionally Tamil speaking with outsiders without giving first preference to the people of those areas. The demography of the two provinces traditionally Tamil speaking was being calculatedly changed. The 1972 and 1978 Constitutions centralised power in the hands of the majority community. Now there is de facto Army rule in the North and East.

Should there be not civilian over-sight in these areas? Does not democracy mean civilian management of local areas? How long is the military going to stay in the North and East? Forever?

For all this, the Soulbury Constitution of 1947 was secular. It did not indicate a unitary structure. It had an inclusive approach. It recognised the multi-ethnic nature of our society and inserted the all-important provision of Section 29.

Our 1972 Constitution, which had no mandate to change the 1947 Constitution and no participation from the elected representatives of the Tamils of North and East, got rid of Section 29, giving no akin provision instead, made Buddhism State Religion and approved of the Sinhala Only Act earlier passed thus ushering in officially the supremacy of the majority community.

Having got so far do you mean to say any Government of the majority community would consent to settle the issues of the minorities? They would want the minorities to creep around the stem if they wanted any succour and that too, individual favours. Look at our budget. Highest for the military. After the war, is it human security that needs precedence or state security? What has prevented the State from granting the legitimate expectations of the people of the North and East that they be allowed to look after their affairs undisturbed by outside forces? Root causes, which gave rise to violence among the Tamil youth, still remain unattended to.

None of the Political Settlements reached with the leaders of the Tamils have been given effect to. Bandaranaike – Chelvanayagam Pact, Dudley Senanayake-Chelvanayagam Pact, Regional Councils’ Legislation under J.R. Jayewardene have been abrogated.

The present President, if I remember right in January 2010, gave an assurance to the Prime Minister of India that he would work along the lines of the Thirteenth Amendment plus. The Thirteenth Amendment is a dead letter today.

Now tell me Ayesha! Do you think any majority community based Government, with a history such as this, would consent to grant rights to the Tamil-speaking people, unless internationally or locally pressured,” Justice Wigneswaran asked.

* * *


In answering a question “What exactly does the Tamil community want,” Justice Wigneswaran said it is “simple”.

“The Tamil-speaking people want to look after their affairs themselves. In legal terminology that is the right of self-determination.”

“They want to be governed in the North and East in their language. They want to go back to the land of their forefathers from temporary living quarters provided by whomsoever. They want their security, law and order to be in the hands of their siblings and progeny not in the hands of outsiders.”

“They want their lands and properties to be administered by themselves; not by outsiders. They want to elect their own representatives without being dictated to by outside agencies, military power or financial power or administrative power.”

“They need to preserve their language, culture, religions and their way of life without outsiders building statues and vihares in their midst with military might.” They need to be freed from mercenaries amongst their midst who plunder and rob at the instigation of outside agencies.”

“All these are not rights which the Tamil speaking people have concocted for themselves. Any people who have certain identities of their own are entitled to ask for self-determination in terms of the international covenants,” the former Supreme Court Judge said.

“Unlike when we were young, many Sinhalese have forgotten or have been made to forget the fact that Tamils occupied this country even before the birth of the Sinhalese language. Their progeny in the North and East are therefore entitled to their unfettered individuality,” he observed.

As a model of political solution he favoured a federal constitution. “Separation is what Prabhakaran asked. Federalism is what the non-violent Chelvanayagam asked,” he said.

After becoming completely hopeless in a 30 years struggle for federal solution, Chelvanayagam decided to call for independent Tamil Eelam in 1976. Prabhakaran's LTTE with local genius achieved a de facto military and territorial parity to address the issue. But ‘internal pressure’ by indigenous efforts was not acceptable to the outside powers, whose competition to keep the issue regional or international, jointly and deliberately tilted the balance, commented a Tamil political analyst in the island.

Justice Wigneswaran’s interview has to be read in between the lines to realise that unless there is internationally recognized parity between the nations in the island, no solutions are going to come. The 13th Amendment is not a beginning but a failed pre-emption, the political analyst commented further.

External Links:
Daily Mirror: A federal constitution is the best for our country